Justene Hill Edwards, "Savings and Trust: The Rise and Betrayal of the Freedman's Bank" (Norton, 2024)
Nov 3, 2024
auto_awesome
Justene Hill Edwards, an associate professor at the University of Virginia and author of 'Unfree Markets', discusses her latest book on the Freedman's Bank, a pivotal institution for freed African Americans post-Civil War. She reveals how the bank was intended to foster economic independence but ultimately collapsed due to mismanagement by its white financiers. Through powerful narratives, she connects this historical betrayal to ongoing issues of inequality in America, emphasizing the importance of financial education in advocating for economic justice.
Enslaved individuals possessed a profound awareness of economic forces, influencing their transition to freedom and shaping their banking aspirations.
The collapse of the Freedman's Bank due to mismanagement profoundly affected African Americans' trust in financial institutions and their path towards economic autonomy.
Deep dives
Understanding Enslaved Peoples' Economy
Enslaved individuals possessed a rudimentary understanding of banking and finance, primarily shaped by their experiences as property. Through narratives, they expressed awareness of how their lives and those of their families were commodified, illustrating a painful recognition of their economic position. For instance, in the narrative of William and Ellen Craft, William reflects on how his family's value was assessed based on age and marketability, highlighting a stark awareness of economic forces even amidst oppression. This foundation of knowledge influenced their transition from slavery to freedom, emphasizing the complex relationship between personal experience and economic understanding.
The Origins of the Freedmen's Bank
The Freedmen's Bank was established in 1865, building on the success of military savings banks created for Black soldiers in 1864. Recognizing the significant deposits made by these soldiers, philanthropists initiated the idea of a bank to support formerly enslaved individuals. However, discussions about governance highlighted a tension regarding the involvement of Black individuals in managing the bank, with early proposals for Black trustees largely unmet. Despite these challenges, the bank emerged as a significant financial entity aimed at providing African Americans with a trustworthy place to save their hard-earned money.
Tensions in Banking Practices
A disconnect occurred between the Freedmen's Bank's administration and its depositors regarding how to use bank accounts, leading to significant tensions. While bank officials hoped depositors would treat accounts as high-yield savings, African Americans primarily sought a secure place for their funds to access when needed for immediate expenses, like purchasing land. This mismatch in expectations created friction, as administrators pressured depositors to keep their money longer to accrue interest. The dissonance undermined trust in the bank and foreshadowed the institutional mismanagement to come.
The Collapse of the Freedmen's Bank
The bank's failure in 1874 marked a pivotal moment, revealing deep-seated issues within its management and impacting African Americans' trust in financial institutions. Under the leadership of Frederick Douglass, the bank attempted to navigate financial difficulties, but it became clear that mismanagement had eroded its foundation. The subsequent runs on the bank reflected widespread distrust among depositors who feared for their savings. Ultimately, this failure had lasting repercussions, significantly shaping African Americans' future relationships with traditional finance and illustrating the broader systemic issues of financial inclusion.
InSavings and Trust: The Rise and Betrayal of the Freedman's Bank(W. W. Norton, 2024), Justene Hill Edwards exposes how the rise and tragic failure of the Freedman’s Bank has shaped economic inequality in America. In the years immediately after the Civil War, tens of thousands of former slaves deposited millions of dollars into the Freedman’s Bank. African Americans envisioned this new bank as a launching pad for economic growth and self-determination. But only nine years after it opened, their trust was betrayed and the Freedman’s Bank collapsed.
Fully informed by new archival findings, historian Justene Hill Edwards unearths a major turning point in American history in this comprehensive account of the Freedman’s Bank and its depositors. She illuminates the hope with which the bank was first envisioned and demonstrates the significant setback that the sabotage of the bank caused in the fight for economic autonomy. Hill Edwards argues for a new interpretation of its tragic failure: the bank’s white financiers drove the bank into the ground, not Fredrick Douglass, its final president, or its Black depositors and cashiers. A page-turning story filled with both well-known figures like Abraham Lincoln, Frederick Douglass, Jay and Henry Cooke, and General O. O. Howard, and less well-known figures like Dr. Charles B. Purvis, John Mercer Langston, Congressman Robert Smalls, and Ellen Baptiste Lubin. Savings and Trust is necessary reading for those seeking to understand the roots of racial economic inequality in America.
Justene Hill Edwards is an associate professor of history at the University of Virginia and the author of both Unfree Markets and a forthcoming Norton Short on the history of inequality in America. She lives in Charlottesville, Virginia. Twitter. Website.
Brian Hamilton is chair of the Department of History and Social Science at Deerfield Academy. Twitter. Website.