Exploring Garland v. Cargill, the debate over bump stocks vs. machine guns. Analysis of Justice Clarence Thomas' stance. Critique of the Supreme Court ruling. Delving into textualism, dissenting opinions, and contrasting policy approaches. Criticism of textualism in gun rights cases and advocating for democratic action in addressing mass shootings.
Justice Thomas categorized bump stocks differently, allowing civilian access to military-grade killing machines.
The podcast delves into the unintended consequences of Juul Labs' actions, leading to the rise of an illegal vape market.
Deep dives
Backfired, The Vaping Wars Podcast Summary
The podcast discusses 'Backfired, The Vaping Wars,' detailing Jewel Labs' unintended consequences. The company intended to help people quit smoking but ended up popularizing jouling, leading to a rise in an illegal vape market. The series delves into business repercussions and unintended outcomes. Listen to 'Backfired' for insights on this complex narrative.
Garland v Cargill Case Overview
The podcast episode dives into the Garland v Cargill case, where federal guidance making bump stocks illegal was overturned. Bump stocks allow semi-automatic firearms to shoot rapidly, akin to machine guns. Justice Clarence Thomas's ruling categorized bump stocks differently, allowing civilians access to military-grade killing machines.
5 to 4 Podcast Analysis
The podcast '5 to 4' critically examines Supreme Court cases affecting civil liberties. The episode highlights how the court's decisions, like in Garland v Cargill, can impact gun control laws and public safety. The hosts dissect the court's rulings with a critical lens, revealing insights into how decisions are made.
Firearm Functionality and Bump Stock Interpretation
The podcast explores the mechanics of bump stocks, devices converting semi-automatic guns to near-automatic weapons. By analyzing the interpretation of 'machine gun' under the National Firearms Act, a comparison is drawn between trigger functions of automatic and semi-automatic firearms. The episode critiques the court's textualist approach and its implications for gun control laws.
Citing Urban Dictionary and wikiHow*, Clarence Thomas argues that a gun that can kill hundreds of people with a single trigger pull is not a machine gun.
*Not actually true but those are the vibes.
If you're not a 5-4 Premium member, you're not hearing every episode! To get first dibs on live show tickets, dig into our Premium episode catalog, membership in our Slack community, and more, join at fivefourpod.com/support.
5-4 is presented by Prologue Projects. Rachel Ward is our producer. Leon Neyfakh and Andrew Parsons provide editorial support. Our researcher is Jonathan DeBruin, and our website was designed by Peter Murphy. Our artwork is by Teddy Blanks at Chips NY, and our theme song is by Spatial Relations.
Follow the show at @fivefourpod on most platforms. On Twitter, find Peter @The_Law_Boy and Rhiannon @AywaRhiannon.