Sober Cast: An (unofficial) Alcoholics Anonymous Podcast AA

Workshop: Has AA Lost It’s Edge?

Jan 17, 2026
Bill C and Jay S dive into the effectiveness of Alcoholics Anonymous, pondering whether it's lost its edge. They analyze early attendance reports, misinterpreted statistics, and the historical success rates that painted AA in a favorable light. The duo discusses AA's influential reach, the growth of related fellowships, and the importance of adapting to modern challenges. They emphasize the role of personal responsibility in carrying AA's message and support newcomers while suggesting effective practices for maintaining group health.
Ask episode
AI Snips
Chapters
Books
Transcript
Episode notes
INSIGHT

Media Boosted Early Growth And Myths

  • Early publicity (Jack Alexander article) dramatically increased AA's visibility and membership.
  • Public recognition shaped early statistics and perceptions of AA's success.
INSIGHT

Misreading Snapshot Surveys

  • Survey snapshots showing 5% at 12 months were misread as long-term success rates.
  • Normalizing and extrapolating the data reveals much higher retention among those already sober longer.
ANECDOTE

Sister Ignatia's Rigorous Screening System

  • Sister Ignatia required Akron AA members to sponsor and sometimes guarantee hospital bills for newcomers.
  • This strict pre-screening and sponsorship produced high early success rates at St. Thomas Hospital.
Get the Snipd Podcast app to discover more snips from this episode
Get the app