Wicked Words - Kate Summerscale: The Suspicions of Mr. Whicher
Aug 28, 2023
auto_awesome
Kate Summerscale, author of The Suspicions of Mr. Whicher, tells the story of a brutal murder in Victorian England and the famous detective who tried to solve it. Topics include the suspicious nature of the case, the abusive family patriarch, child labor in factories, the impact of class and power on detective investigations, and the various theories and suspects involved. Lessons learned from crime fiction and true crime stories are also explored.
The Suspicions of Mr. Whicher highlights the importance of psychological insight in crime investigations, demonstrating that understanding human behavior and motivations can be pivotal in solving complex crimes.
Detective Witcher's accusations against Constance Kent in the murder case were met with backlash and skepticism, serving as a reminder that relying solely on intuition without concrete evidence can lead to a decline in reputation and career.
Deep dives
The Murder Case and the Initial Investigation
In the summer of 1860, three-year-old Savile Kent is found dead with his throat slashed at the family's grand house in Wiltshire, England. The local police investigate but fail to find any leads, leading to national outrage. Detective Jack Witcher and his partner from Scotland Yard are called in to solve the case. Witcher suspects that the killer must be someone within the house, as the window used to gain access seems like a decoy. He becomes convinced that Constance Kent, the 16-year-old half-sister of Savile, is the culprit. However, he cannot gather enough evidence to support his theory, and his accusations are met with backlash and skepticism.
The Controversial Investigation
Witcher's investigation focuses on Constance Kent, suspecting her of harboring resentment against her father and stepmother, leading her to commit the crime. He scrutinizes her missing nightdress and intimates the involvement of a possible accomplice. Despite the lack of physical evidence, Witcher accuses Constance, causing his reputation to suffer and his career to decline. The family vehemently defends Constance, denying any involvement and casting doubt on Witcher's investigation. Eventually, Witcher's accusations are discredited, and Constance is not charged in the murder case.
Constance's Confession and Redemption
After five years, Constance Kent confesses to the murder during her stay in London. She claims that she killed Savile as an act of vengeance against her stepmother, who she felt had betrayed her. Constance's confession clears the rest of the Kent family from suspicion, and her father's reputation improves. Witcher, who had been somewhat vindicated by her confession, continues his career as a private investigator. Constance serves 20 years in prison before being released and later moves to Australia, where she lives until the age of 101.
The Importance of Psychological Insight
The case of Savile Kent's murder emphasizes the significance of psychological insight in crime investigations. Witcher's ability to read character and intuition play a pivotal role in his suspicion of Constance, despite the lack of concrete evidence. The story serves as a reminder that understanding human behavior and motivations can be instrumental in solving complex crimes, even when physical evidence is lacking or inconclusive.
The brutal murder of a 3-year-old shocked Victorian England not only because of how it happened, but because of who the police suspected. Could one of Britain’s most famous detectives solve the case? Author Kate Summerscale tells us the story at the center of her book, The Suspicions of Mr. Whicher.
Support this podcast by shopping our latest sponsor deals and promotions at this link: https://bit.ly/4dsqzI1