The Origins Podcast with Lawrence Krauss

Alex Byrne and Moti Gorin | The War on Science Interviews | Day 18

Aug 11, 2025
Alex Byrne, a Lawrence Rockefeller Professor of Philosophy at MIT, and bioethicist Moti Gorin dive into the ideological challenges facing academia today. They tackle the contentious debates around gender-affirming care, examining its efficacy and the impact of academic freedom. The discussion highlights the philosophical complexities surrounding child identity and medical interventions, as well as the dangers of ideological conformity in scholarship. They advocate for transparency and open dialogue, emphasizing the need to reclaim free speech in academic settings.
Ask episode
AI Snips
Chapters
Books
Transcript
Episode notes
ANECDOTE

From Physics To Philosophy

  • Alex Byrne began in physics, switched to mathematics, then later studied philosophy and earned a PhD at Princeton.
  • He says he moved to the U.S. and stayed in academia.
ANECDOTE

Cancellation Sparked Investigation

  • Rebecca Tuvel's 2017 cancellation and later attacks on Kathleen Stock spurred Alex Byrne to study sex and gender literature.
  • He found leading philosophers attempted to destroy colleagues' reputations and poor-quality scholarship.
INSIGHT

Dutch Protocol Guardrails Broken

  • The Dutch protocol required persistent early-onset gender dysphoria, family support, and no major psychopathology before medical intervention.
  • Alex Byrne says U.S. clinicians relaxed these guardrails and a more permissive, riskier model emerged.
Get the Snipd Podcast app to discover more snips from this episode
Get the app