Intelligence Squared Debate: Save Our Private Schools – VAT Should Not Be Charged On Private School Fees, Part Two
Mar 10, 2024
Fraser Nelson, Editor of The Spectator, debates the taxation of private school fees, arguing for maintaining their financial privileges. In contrast, Ash Sarkar, a contributing editor at Novara Media, and Melissa Benn, a writer and campaigner, advocate for a comprehensive school system, highlighting the inequalities perpetuated by enhanced funding for private schools. They discuss the societal implications of VAT on private education, the need for equitable funding for public schools, and the emotional toll on families amidst the funding disparities.
AI Snips
Chapters
Transcript
Episode notes
Perceptions of Privilege
- Fraser Nelson found that he was perceived as posh in London due to attending private school, even though the government funded his education.
- He now accepts this "inverted snobbery" but finds it unfair and divisive.
Funding and Attainment Gap
- Ash Sarkar acknowledges increased attainment in state schools, driven by London schools' funding initiatives.
- However, she argues that class attainment gaps persist elsewhere due to underfunding, exacerbated by the private sector's political influence.
Limited Impact from Private Schools
- An audience member, a state school governor, shared his experience of seeing limited real-world help from independent schools for state schools despite some initiatives.
- He highlighted the positive impact of the London Challenge and Labour government initiatives under Tony Blair on improving state education.