Chenjerai Kumanyika, creator of the new series exploring the NYPD's origins, joins the discussion. The hosts analyze shifting voter dynamics in the Sun Belt, revealing how economic concerns and issues like abortion are reshaping political loyalties. They also critique Trump's campaign struggles, including declining rally activity and a focus on television ads. Kumanyika explores the NYPD's historical context, linking policing issues to systemic problems in public safety and the need for reform in marginalized communities.
The podcast emphasizes the historical connection between media narratives and policing, illustrating how perceptions of danger have targeted marginalized communities throughout American history.
Listeners are reminded that the NYPD's origins involved enforcing oppressive laws like the Fugitive Slave Act, highlighting systemic racial profiling and the maintenance of societal status quos.
The discussion calls for a reevaluation of police effectiveness, illustrating a disconnect between public safety needs and current policing practices amidst ongoing demands for reform.
Deep dives
The Impact of Media on Policing
The evolution of policing in America, particularly the NYPD, has been significantly shaped by media narratives. In the 19th century, newspapers played a crucial role in defining what was perceived as dangerous, often targeting poor and Black communities. This media portrayal not only influenced public perception but also guided political action and the establishment of police forces designed to control these 'threats.' The series emphasizes that the historical relationship between media and policing demands critical examination, as it continues to affect contemporary views on safety and police efficacy.
Historical Roots of the NYPD
The origins of the NYPD provide a stark reminder of its role in perpetuating systemic oppression, especially against Black individuals. The police department was initially deployed to enforce laws such as the Fugitive Slave Act, which enforced the return of escaped slaves. This historical context highlights not just the roots of racial profiling, but also a broader pattern where policing has often maintained the status quo rather than protecting vulnerable populations. The discussion sheds light on how these early functions set a precedent for relations between the police and marginalized communities.
Personal Connections to the NYPD's History
The host's personal connection to the NYPD's history, particularly through his father’s activism, underscores the real-life implications of police actions. His father's involvement in protests against police brutality was met with surveillance from the NYPD, exemplifying the department's historical antagonism towards civil rights. Watching footage of his father being surveilled complicates the narrative of policing, revealing the system's deep-seated reliance on intimidation and control. This connection emphasizes the broader historical and personal stakes involved in discussions about policing and public safety.
Ineffectiveness and Misallocation of Police Resources
The inefficacy of police in fostering real safety is called into question, particularly examining high-profile incidents involving NYPD. Statistics reveal low clearance rates for crimes, with less than half reported, highlighting a failure in police effectiveness. These shortcomings are juxtaposed with instances of police violence, suggesting a pattern where policing does not equate to public safety. The series challenges viewers to rethink the current model of policing and its alignment with actual community needs, proposing a shift towards addressing the root causes of crime.
The Political Landscape of Policing
The political challenges surrounding police reform present a significant barrier to meaningful change. Following the momentum of the Black Lives Matter movement, public sentiment has shifted towards a desire for reform, but political leaders have largely maintained the status quo. The series indicates a growing disconnect between current policing practices and community safety, with politicians often opting for increased funding rather than genuine reform. This complex interplay reveals the necessity for informed public discourse and accountability, calling for reassessment of what constitutes safety and justice.
The Path Forward for Accountability and Reform
The conversation surrounding police reform often lacks a clear, actionable framework, creating confusion among the public. Various polls indicate a significant demand for reform, suggesting that the majority of Americans recognize the need for major changes to current policing practices. However, defined actions that promote accountability, such as adequate oversight and community engagement, are seldom articulated. The series advocates for a collective understanding of safety that encompasses community-centric approaches, fostering dialogues that can reshape the role of policing in American society.
Six weeks out from Election Day, new polls show Harris leading nationally, but Trump still ahead in key Sun Belt states. Jon, Lovett, and Tommy dive into Harris's push for a second debate, Trump's undisciplined campaign operation, and Mark Robinson staying in the North Carolina governor’s race— even after his team quit. Then, Tommy chats with Chenjerai Kumanyika about his new series, Empire City: The Untold Origin Story of the NYPD.
For a closed-captioned version of this episode, click here. For a transcript of this episode, please email transcripts@crooked.com and include the name of the podcast.
Get the Snipd podcast app
Unlock the knowledge in podcasts with the podcast player of the future.
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode
Save any moment
Hear something you like? Tap your headphones to save it with AI-generated key takeaways
Share & Export
Send highlights to Twitter, WhatsApp or export them to Notion, Readwise & more
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode