
The Tech Policy Press Podcast Exploring Belief and Belonging in a Fractured Online Age
Dec 4, 2025
Calum Lister Matheson, an associate professor at the University of Pittsburgh and author of Post-Weird, delves into the psychology behind community beliefs in a fractured digital age. He discusses how fantasy shapes our understanding of reality amidst declining consensus and the evolving role of technology in heightening division. Matheson highlights case studies like Sandy Hook conspiracism and the dynamics within pro-anorexia groups, emphasizing the need for nuanced rhetoric and the dangers of fringe beliefs gaining political traction.
AI Snips
Chapters
Books
Transcript
Episode notes
Unconscious Drives Shape Public Acts
- Psychoanalytic concepts help explain actions people themselves can't fully understand.
- The unconscious motivates public behaviors that purely rational accounts miss.
Nostalgia Masks Past Fragmentation
- Nostalgia for a unified mainstream is itself a fantasy.
- We are less willing to pretend unity now, revealing real fragmentation.
Symbols Lose Their Automatic Authority
- Symbolic efficiency means symbols stand for authority and social order.
- That capacity erodes, so symbols like the white coat no longer automatically command trust.





