Israel’s nightmare scenario: 'Netanyahu is up to his neck in criminal investigations as war rages'
Apr 3, 2025
auto_awesome
Amir Tibon, a Haaretz columnist known for his keen insights into Israeli politics, discusses the alarming intersection of Prime Minister Netanyahu's legal troubles and the ongoing conflict with Hamas. He describes the situation as a 'nightmare scenario' with 59 hostages still held captive. Tibon also reveals how political maneuvering, particularly regarding the Shin Bet chief appointment, reflects internal party pressures. His analysis sheds light on the precarious balance between national security and political scandal amidst escalating violence.
Netanyahu's legal troubles have led to chaotic governance, undermining national security focus while addressing 59 hostages held by Hamas.
The failed appointment of Eli Sharvit reflects Netanyahu's difficulty in balancing political pressures from far-right factions amidst ongoing legal challenges.
Deep dives
Political Turmoil Amidst Ongoing Conflict
The recent political events in Israel have highlighted significant turmoil within the government, particularly surrounding Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu's actions amidst the escalating conflict with Hamas. Netanyahu's abrupt firing and subsequent reinstatement of the Shin Bet chief occurred just as he was involved in a corruption trial, demonstrating a chaotic governance structure prioritizing personal legal issues over national security concerns. As Netanyahu faced police questioning related to the Qatargate scandal, he was criticized for focusing more on internal political maneuvering than on the dire situation regarding the 59 hostages held by Hamas. This series of events encapsulates the precarious balance he must maintain between appeasing his political allies and addressing the nation's pressing security challenges.
Strategic Appointments and Political Calculations
Netanyahu's attempt to appoint Eli Sharvit as the Shin Bet head reflects the complexities of navigating Israeli politics and public perception amidst his legal troubles. Initially seen as a strategic move to present a competent and non-political figure, Sharvit's appointment was quickly rescinded due to pressures from extremist factions within Netanyahu's own party. These factions viewed Sharvit's past anti-government activism unfavorably, leading to rapid political backlash that forced Netanyahu to reverse his decision. This incident underscores Netanyahu's struggle to maintain a façade of stability while grappling with the fallout from ongoing investigations that could undermine his authority.
Hostage Negotiations and Public Sentiment
Negotiations for the release of hostages held by Hamas remain stagnant, primarily due to Netanyahu's refusal to compromise on the war against Hamas. Despite a proposed deal that could involve a temporary ceasefire in exchange for the return of hostages, Netanyahu's commitment to eradicating Hamas creates a considerable barrier to progress. This situation is further complicated by public sentiment in Israel, which largely favors ending the conflict for the sake of hostages' release, contrasting sharply with Netanyahu's hardline approach. Many within Israel feel their government is out of touch, as seen in the protests and calls for negotiations that prioritize the lives of hostages over political posturing.
For Haaretz columnist Amir Tibon, the renewed fighting in Israel with hostages still in captivity, as scandal unfolds around Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu, represents a “nightmare scenario.”
Tibon pointed to the fact after the two-month reprieve of a cease-fire and hostage release in the first stage of the deal that Netanyahu subsequently abandoned, “we now find ourselves with59 Israeli hostages held by Hamas in the tunnels of Gaza; Israeli troops on the ground; rockets are being fired at northern, southern and central Israel. And instead of dealing with the security needs of the country, we have a prime minister who is running from court to the police investigation. If I had written this three years ago in Haaretz as a scenario of what will happen under Netanyahu, everybody would have dismissed it as hateful anti-Bibi material – a nightmare scenario that will never come true. But this is what is happening right now."
Tibon added that Netanyahu’s lightning-quick reversal of his decision to appoint former naval commander Eli Sharvit as Shin Bet director was driven by “dissatisfaction” with his choice by the far-right wing of his own Likud party. The Prime Minister attributing the flip-flop to pressure from the Trump administration, he said, was “an absolute lie.”