The Dershow Is it constitutional for Trump to accept an airplane from Qatar?
May 13, 2025
The podcast kicks off with a lively discussion comparing baseball legends Pete Rose and Ty Cobb, diving into their contentious Hall of Fame exclusions. A humorous anecdote about receiving gifts from former presidents leads to an exploration of the legal and ethical implications of foreign gifts, such as a hypothetical $400 million airplane from Qatar. The conversation shifts to significant constitutional issues like habeas corpus, birthright citizenship, and the complexities surrounding due process, providing listeners with engaging insights into current legal debates.
AI Snips
Chapters
Transcript
Episode notes
Pete Rose Hall of Fame Story
- Pete Rose, a legendary baseball figure, was recently reinstated and made eligible for the Hall of Fame. - Alan Dershowitz has supported Pete Rose's admission for over 20 years, comparing him to Ty Cobb.
Emoluments Clause Explained
- The emoluments clause prohibits acceptance of gifts from foreign rulers without Congress's consent. - Gifts to the sitting president, like a $400 million plane from Qatar, don't violate if given to the U.S. government, not the individual.
Post-Presidency Gift Rules
- After a president leaves office, gifts like planes become government property or part of presidential libraries. - The recipient cannot personally keep or use such gifts without paying fair rent or costs, or it triggers constitutional issues.