Theories of Everything with Curt Jaimungal Paul Vanderklay on Peterson, Vervaeke, and why Sam Harris is wrong
Aug 24, 2020
Paul Vanderklay, a minister in the Christian Reformed Church of North America, delves into the influence of prominent thinkers like Jordan Peterson, John Vervaeke, and Jonathan Pageau on the evolving landscape of Christianity. He discusses the tension between modern interpretations of faith and traditional values, questioning the essence of 'new Christianity.' Vanderklay critiques Sam Harris and explores the philosophical debates surrounding faith versus reason, as well as the complexities of identity and belief in a postmodern world.
01:27:42
Peterson Poster
- After Paul Vanderklay's first video, a church member gave him a poster about Jordan Peterson.
- The poster jokingly advertised "Dr. Peterson's Sort Yourself Out Syrup" as a remedy for various societal ills.
Speaker Styles
- Paul Vanderklay analyzes the approaches of Peterson, Vervaeke, and Pageau.
- He labels Peterson as a "preacher," Pageau as an "artist-teacher," and Vervaeke as a "scientist-guru."
Christianity's Revival
- The resurgence of Christian interest, influenced by figures like Peterson, is analyzed.
- Vanderklay suggests this revival differs from previous ones and connects it to post-World War I secularism.
Get the Snipd Podcast app to discover more snips from this episode
Get the app 1 chevron_right 2 chevron_right 3 chevron_right 4 chevron_right 5 chevron_right 6 chevron_right 7 chevron_right 8 chevron_right
Intro
00:00 • 2min
Journey to Meaning: Exploring Influence and Community
02:12 • 8min
Resurgence and Reflection: Christianity in Modern Context
10:08 • 26min
Faith vs. Reason: The Resurrection Debate
36:26 • 5min
Faith, Rationality, and Human Behavior in Religious Contexts
41:30 • 3min
The Parable of Jonah: Belief and Identity
44:18 • 8min
Philosophical Explorations of Freedom and Social Structure
52:06 • 18min
Touba Mbake and the Quest for Spiritual Resistance
01:10:33 • 13min
Major Works of Wilfred Sellars
Philosophical Contributions
Wilfrid Stalker Sellars
Wilfred Sellars was a leading American philosopher who developed a unified philosophical system.
His notable works include 'Empiricism and the Philosophy of Mind,' 'Science, Perception, and Reality,' and 'Philosophy and the Scientific Image of Man.' These works address the reconciliation of scientific and manifest images of reality, critiquing foundationalist epistemology and exploring the nature of mind and knowledge.
Notable Works of Charles Taylor
A Collection of Influential Philosophical Contributions
Charles Margrave Taylor
Charles Taylor's works span a wide range of philosophical topics, including critiques of behaviorism in 'The Explanation of Behaviour', analyses of modern identity in 'Sources of the Self', and explorations of secularism in 'A Secular Age'.
His writings have been translated into numerous languages and have significantly impacted contemporary philosophical discourse.
תולדות האמונה הישראלית
Yeḥezkel Kaufmann
This monumental work by Yehezkel Kaufmann examines the development of Israelite religion, arguing that monotheism was an original and revolutionary concept that emerged with Moses.
Kaufmann rejects evolutionary theories of religious development, emphasizing the unique nature of Israelite monotheism.
What's Divine about Divine Law? Early Perspectives
Christine Hayes
Christine Hayes's work, such as 'What's Divine about Divine Law? Early Perspectives', delves into the historical and theological aspects of religious law.
Her books are recognized for their scholarly depth and insight into Jewish studies.
Works of Dostoevsky and Tolstoy
Works of Dostoevsky and Tolstoy
A Comparative Analysis
Fyodor Dostoevsky
Leo Tolstoy
While there isn't a specific book titled 'Works of Dostoevsky and Tolstoy', their individual works are renowned for their contributions to Russian literature.
Dostoevsky's novels delve into the human psyche and existentialism, while Tolstoy's works explore societal dynamics and morality.
Both authors are celebrated for their profound insights into the human condition.
The Works of Tertullian
Complete Extant Works
Quintus Septimius Florens Tertullianus
This eBook presents Tertullian's complete extant works, featuring both English translations and the original Latin texts.
It includes apologetic writings like 'Apologeticus', polemic works against heresies, and practical treatises on Christian living.
The collection is beautifully illustrated and provides concise introductions to his life and works.
Works of Bishop Robert Barron
A Collection of Theological and Spiritual Writings
Robert Emmett Barron
Bishop Robert Barron is a prolific author with works spanning theology, spirituality, and culture.
His writings include books like 'Catholicism', 'Seeds of the Word', and 'To Light a Fire on the Earth', among others.
His works are known for their depth and accessibility, making them appealing to a wide audience.
Works of Touba Mbake
Not Available
Touba Mbake
The Muridiyya movement, founded by Amadou Bamba Mbacke, is a significant Sufi order in Senegal.
If 'Works of Touba Mbake' refers to writings related to this movement, it might explore themes of Sufism, Islamic teachings, and the history of Touba, Senegal.
For the life of the world
Alexander Schmemann
Alexander Schmemann's "For the Life of the World" is a seminal work in liturgical theology, exploring the profound connection between Christian worship and daily life.
Schmemann challenges modern interpretations of church and worship, emphasizing the Eucharist as the central act of Christian existence.
He argues that true worship is not merely a ritual but a transformative encounter with God that permeates all aspects of life.
The book offers a rich understanding of the liturgical year and its significance in shaping Christian identity and practice.
Schmemann's work has significantly influenced contemporary liturgical movements and continues to inspire theologians and practitioners alike.
Recent Works of Ross Douthat
Notable Books by Ross Douthat
Ross Douthat
Ross Douthat has written several influential books, including 'The Decadent Society', which critiques modern societal trends, and 'Believe', which explores the importance of religious belief.
His memoir, 'The Deep Places', reflects on his personal struggle with Lyme disease and its impact on his faith.
Works of Brett Sockold
Works of Brett Sockold
Brett Sockold
Notable Works of Sam Harris
A Collection of His Major Books
Sam Harris
Sam Harris is renowned for his influential books such as 'The End of Faith', 'Letter to a Christian Nation', 'The Moral Landscape', 'Free Will', 'Lying', 'Waking Up', and 'Islam and the Future of Tolerance'.
His works explore themes of rationality, ethics, neuroscience, and spirituality without religion.
Works of Jonathan Pageau
Not Available
Jonathan Pageau
Jonathan Pageau is a prominent figure in symbolic storytelling and Orthodox iconography.
His notable works include 'God's'Dog: Monster', a graphic novel, and 'The Tale of Snow White and the Widow Queen', part of an eight-book series retelling classic fairy tales.
No book titled 'Proof of God's Existence' by Jordan B. Peterson
Jordan Peterson's views on God and religion are explored in various works
Jordan B Peterson
While there is no specific book titled 'Proof of God's Existence' by Jordan B. Peterson, his discussions on God and religion emphasize moral responsibility and the importance of living ethically.
He often explores biblical narratives and their relevance to modern life, encouraging individuals to act as if God exists to foster a sense of purpose and moral direction.
Works of Sargon of Akkad
Works of Sargon of Akkad
Sargon of Akkad
Notable Works of Thomas Nagel
A Collection of Influential Philosophical Contributions
Thomas Nagel
Thomas Nagel's works include 'Mortal Questions', 'The View from Nowhere', and 'Mind and Cosmos', which explore themes of consciousness, ethics, and political theory.
His essays, such as 'What Is It Like to Be a Bat?', have significantly impacted the philosophy of mind.
Notable Works of Alexander Dugin
A Collection of Influential Books
Alexander Dugin
Alexander Dugin is renowned for his contributions to Russian neo-Eurasianism.
His notable works include 'The Fourth Political Theory', 'Eurasian Mission', and 'Foundations of Geopolitics', which have significantly influenced Russian political thought and foreign policy.
The Hobbit and The Lord of the Rings
Deluxe Edition
John Ronald Reuel Tolkien
This collection includes 'The Hobbit', a classic children's fantasy novel about Bilbo Baggins' adventures, and 'The Lord of the Rings', a trilogy that follows Frodo Baggins on a perilous quest to destroy the One Ring.
Both works are set in Middle-earth, a richly detailed world filled with magic, mythical creatures, and epic battles between good and evil.
Notable Works of René Girard
A Collection of Major Contributions
René Girard
René Girard's works span multiple disciplines, including literary criticism, anthropology, and philosophy.
His notable books include 'Deceit, Desire, and the Novel', 'Violence and the Sacred', and 'Things Hidden Since the Foundation of the World'.
These works introduce key concepts such as mimetic desire and the scapegoat mechanism, which are central to his theory.
Works of Augustine of Hippo
A Collection of Major Works
Augustine of Hippo
This collection likely includes some of Augustine's most famous works such as 'The City of God', 'The Confessions', and 'On Christian Doctrine'.
These writings have profoundly shaped Western Christian thought and continue to be studied for their theological and philosophical insights.
The Case Against Reality
Why Evolution Hid the Truth from Our Eyes
Donald Hoffman
In this book, Donald Hoffman challenges the notion that our senses report back objective reality.
He argues that evolution has sculpted our minds for fitness, not to accurately represent reality, leading to a mismatch between our perceptions and the true nature of the world.
Hoffman introduces the concept of 'Fitness Beats Truth' and uses analogies like the computer desktop to explain how our consciousness interacts with the world in a way that is useful but not necessarily reflective of underlying reality.
He also proposes 'Conscious Realism,' suggesting that conscious agents create the perception of an objective reality, rather than the other way around.
Saving the appearances
Owen Barfield
Meaning Crisis
Meaning Crisis
John Vervaeke
A Religion That Isn't a Religion
A Religion That Isn't a Religion
Alistair McGrath
Magnetic mountain
Stephen Kotkin
This book provides a street-level account of what Stalinism meant to the masses of ordinary people who lived it.
Kotkin argues that Stalinism offered itself as an opportunity for enlightenment and a new civilization based on the repudiation of capitalism.
The book depicts a wide range of life, from blast furnace workers to families struggling with housing and services, and examines the relationship between the state's ambitions and the dreams of ordinary people.
It is thematically organized and closely focused, signaling a new stage in the writing of Soviet social history.
Douglas Murray's Works
Notable Books and Columns
Douglas Murray
Douglas Murray is a prominent author and commentator known for his books such as 'The Strange Death of Europe', 'The Madness of Crowds', and 'The War on the West'.
His works often explore themes of immigration, identity politics, and cultural shifts in the Western world.
Murray's writing is characterized by its provocative nature and has been praised by conservatives while criticized by progressives.
The book of Jude
H. L. Heijkoop
In 'The Book of Jude' by H. L. Heijkoop, the author delves into the biblical text to explore the subject of the coming apostasy, where men may turn the grace of God into a license for sin.
This work is a valuable resource for Bible students, offering detailed analysis and interpretation of the Book of Jude.
Silence
Albrecht Selge
Dominion
The Power of Man, the Suffering of Animals, and the Call to Mercy
Matthew Scully
In 'Dominion,' Matthew Scully presents a comprehensive and eloquent case against the mistreatment of animals.
The book delves into various aspects of animal suffering, including factory farming, hunting, whaling, and laboratory experiments.
Scully challenges the notion that humans have unlimited dominion over animals, as suggested by biblical interpretations, and argues for a moral and compassionate approach to animal treatment.
He draws on both religious and scientific perspectives to make his case, emphasizing the importance of empathy and the recognition of animal consciousness and suffering.
The book is a call to action for reform and a plea for human benevolence and mercy towards animals.
Hardcore History
Dan Carlin
In his first book, Dan Carlin delves into a broad range of historical topics, challenging conventional views and presenting history in a fresh and compelling manner.
The book covers the end of the Bronze Age, the fall of major empires, the devastating effects of plagues and famines, and modern concerns such as nuclear warfare.
Carlin's approach is characterized by his ability to humanize historical events, pose alternative perspectives, and make the past relevant to the present.
His narrative is enriched by quotes from historical figures and historians, and he presents a well-researched and engaging account of historical events.
Paul Vanderklay is a minister in the Christian Reformed Church of North America. In this conversation we talk about Jordan Peterson's / John Vervaeke's / Jonathan Pageau's and Sam Harris' influence on "new Christianity."
This wasn't going to be releaseed because Paul Vanderklay and I had our schedule's jumbled; meaning, I had simultaneous people vying for my attention due to double-booking meetings and as a result, am not as present as I would have liked to be. However, due to a few requests I'm releasing and hopefully you enjoy, since Peter does a superlative job in my absence (despite the issues with the sound quality). If you'd like Part 2 with Paul Vanderklay, let me know and leave your questions for him below. - Curt Jaimungal
PAUL VANDERKLAY YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCGsDIP_K6J6VSTqlq-9IPlg Twitter: https://twitter.com/PaulVanderKlay
JOHN VERVAEKE YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/user/johnvervaeke
JONATHAN PAGEAU YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCtCTSf3UwRU14nYWr_xm-dQ Twitter: https://twitter.com/PageauJonathan
INFO FOR CURT JAIMUNGAL Patreon *NEW*: https://patreon.com/curtjaimungal Twitter: https://twitter.com/bluthefilm
* * *
0:00:00 Introduction to Paul Vanderklay 0:02:55 What are the pros and cons of Jordan Peterson's, John Vervaeke's, and Jonathan Pageau's approaches? 0:08:10 How Christian is this "new Christianity" put forward by people like Peterson, and Jung? 0:10:04 Is this the same old debate that Dostoevsky / Nietzsche referred to before the 1900's? 0:13:15 On Solzhenitsyn and the new definition of "religion" 0:16:32 What makes someone a Christian? 0:20:42 What is God? (thoughts on the Sam Harris / Peterson debate) 0:24:24 Deriding God by analogizing him to "Zeus" is incorrect 0:27:30 What's the relationship between Christianity, Secularism, and the State 0:34:16 Can you rationally prove God's existence? 0:44:40 Is Sam Harris a Christian? 0:47:47 How does "religion without religion" make sense? 0:53:19 Does freedom just mean "more choice"?
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices