The Ongoing Tug-of-War Between Tradition and Change - A Conversation with Jeff Strong
Mar 8, 2025
auto_awesome
Jeff Strong, a guest speaker and researcher focused on faith and church participation, shares intriguing insights from a survey involving the Latter-day Saint community. He discusses the complex relationship between tradition and change, examining the challenges and joys individuals face in their faith journeys. Jeff emphasizes the importance of community and the power of shared experiences, revealing how connection helps alleviate feelings of isolation. He also draws parallels to cultural factors shaping belonging and meaning, urging listeners to embrace tensions for personal growth.
The survey revealed that 60% of respondents feel a lack of belonging within church culture, indicating a need for greater inclusion.
A prominent theme discussed was the tension between tradition and change, reflecting a universal struggle within faith communities today.
Many participants desire church culture to prioritize Christ-like teachings over rigid adherence to tradition, emphasizing the need for cultural evolution.
Deep dives
Interfaith Gathering and Community Engagement
The upcoming Wider Circles event, an interfaith gathering hosted by Faith Matters, is designed to foster community and dialogue among various religious traditions. Scheduled for Sunday, March 9th, it features Charu Das of the Spanish Fort Krishna Temple, who will share insights on Hinduism. Attendees are encouraged to bring questions and families as the event is free, emphasizing inclusion and engagement in interfaith discussions. Participants can RSVP to reserve seats, showcasing the community's commitment to open dialogue and understanding.
Insights from Faith Matters Audience Survey
A survey conducted within the Faith Matters community revealed significant insights into the experiences and challenges of church members. With over 1,600 respondents, the survey highlighted a diverse group that remains dedicated yet grapples with complexities surrounding faith and tradition. An important theme identified was the tension between rigidity of tradition and the necessity for change, reflecting a universal struggle within faith communities. This complex relationship often leads to feelings of devotion alongside internal conflict, underscoring a need for support and understanding.
Challenges of Belonging and Comfort in Church Culture
Many participants expressed feelings of discomfort within church culture, noting a lack of belonging that significantly affects their engagement. Survey results indicated that 60% of respondents do not feel a sense of belonging, with nearly half expressing discomfort with the prevailing church culture. Common concerns included the perceived prioritization of adherence to strict norms over individual beliefs and experiences, leading to feelings of isolation. This ongoing struggle points to the need for a more inclusive and accepting culture that can embrace diverse perspectives within the faith community.
The Role of Culture in Faith Experiences
The survey analyzed the impact of church culture on individual faith experiences, revealing that cultural factors often overshadow foundational teachings. While other issues like history and policy disagreements contribute to discontent, many respondents emphasized how cultural dynamics exacerbate their struggles. A substantial portion of participants highlighted a desire for church culture to be more accepting and focused on Christ-like teachings, rather than rigid adherence to tradition. This insight calls for reflection on how church culture can evolve to better serve its members while still upholding essential doctrines.
Embracing Tension and Navigating Change
Navigating the inherent tension between tradition and change is a shared challenge within the Faith Matters community. Many respondents acknowledged that their experiences of faith often involve reconciling conflicting feelings about church teachings and personal beliefs. The survey underscored the importance of community support as individuals grapple with these tensions, highlighting the value of authentic dialogue and shared experiences. Ultimately, fostering an environment where individuals feel safe to express their struggles can lead to personal growth and a stronger sense of unity within the faith community.
This week, we’re welcoming back our good friend Jeff Strong.
Last year, Jeff and his team sent out a survey to the Faith Matters audience as part of a larger research project on faith and church participation. Over 1,600 of you responded, and the results were fascinating! We’re excited to share them with you today. What emerged was a picture of a significant and often unheard cross-section of the Church—a community of people who are deeply devoted but also wrestling, holding both conviction and complexity, faith and struggle, all at once.
In this conversation, Jeff walks us through some of the most powerful insights from the survey, with a special focus on culture and aspects of our faith experience that are shaping our sense of belonging, meaning, and connection. He explores what people love most about being part of this tradition, where they encounter real challenges.
One of the clearest themes in the survey is the tension between tradition and change—a familiar story in faith traditions across the world. Jeff explores what it means to hold that complexity well, in our families, community, and our own hearts. He addresses the power of finding others who are walking a similar path, and why recognizing we’re not alone in this wrestle can be so meaningful.
I want to mention that there are a few visuals in this conversation that Jeff does a great job describing but you can see the slides he talks about in the YouTube version of this episode. To everyone who participated in the survey, thank you. It has been such a gift to see that none of us is alone here. We’re so grateful to be in it with you—asking hard questions, holding onto what we love, and finding our way forward together.
And with that, here’s our conversation with Jeff Strong.
Get the Snipd podcast app
Unlock the knowledge in podcasts with the podcast player of the future.
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode
Save any moment
Hear something you like? Tap your headphones to save it with AI-generated key takeaways
Share & Export
Send highlights to Twitter, WhatsApp or export them to Notion, Readwise & more
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode