Season 6 FINALE: Jordan Peterson Wrestles with God/Ben at MSNBC (ft. Matt McManus & Robert Myles)
Dec 27, 2024
auto_awesome
Matt McManus, a political theorist and commentator, and Robert Myles, a biblical scholar, join Ben Burgis to explore Jordan Peterson's 'We Who Wrestle with God.' The trio humorously critiques Peterson's take on Marx, emphasizing his misunderstandings. They also delve into political discourse surrounding Obama's legacy, shedding light on media reactions and liberal responses. Throughout, the discussion highlights the complexities of biblical texts, Marxist interpretations, and the need for deeper engagement with ideology and morality in contemporary debates.
The podcast critiques the public backlash against the health insurance industry, highlighting a deep disconnect between human life value and commercial interests.
Ben Shapiro's reaction to healthcare-related empathy raises questions about accountability and the systemic issues affecting emotional responses in the medical field.
Historical patterns of political violence are examined, challenging the notion that such actions incite genuine societal shifts or meaningful change.
A discussion on Obama's comments reveals skepticism about leadership narratives that fail to address persistent systemic inequities faced by marginalized groups.
The hosts emphasize the importance of recognizing resistance as vital for societal growth and political change, advocating for continuous engagement with entrenched systems.
Deep dives
The Outpouring of Hatred for the Health Insurance Industry
The podcast discusses a significant public backlash against the health insurance industry following a tragic incident involving Brian Thompson, who was shot in New York City. Many commentators on social media expressed a stark lack of sympathy for him, attributing their feelings to their negative experiences with the health insurance system. Comments ranged from cold acknowledgments of financial burdens to harsh criticisms of the insurance system that many felt contributed to widespread suffering. This sentiment showcases a disconnect between the value of human life and the commercial interests of the insurance industry.
Critique of Ben Shapiro's Response
Ben Shapiro's reaction to the incident and the comments made by an ER nurse highlight the polarizing nature of the discourse around health care. Shapiro critiques the nurse for lacking empathy, suggesting that those caught up in the 'radical left' narratives are responsible for the lack of compassion shown. However, this response is called into question, as it implies that Shapiro is missing the broader context of systemic issues that affect those in the medical field and their emotional responses. It raises an important debate about accountability, blame, and the moral implications of economic systems and individual experiences.
Historical and Societal Context of Violence
The discussion turns to the effectiveness of political violence throughout history, questioning whether such acts genuinely inspire societal change. Notably, the podcast mentions that despite public outbursts against the CEO responsible for the insurance denials, there remains a historical pattern of violence without substantial shifts in the political landscape. This context challenges conventional narratives about political assassinations or violent protests being catalysts for social movements. The recurring theme of societal instability persists, fueled by an acknowledgment of past failures to effect meaningful change.
Public Sentiment Towards Political Figures
In analyzing public sentiment, the podcast highlights how individuals express their frustrations with political figures and institutions across social media platforms. The hosts note that many comments seem politically neutral yet focus on personal grievances and desires for basic healthcare and fairness in the system. This reveals a growing frustration not confined to party lines but broadly shared among the population concerning health care access and political representation. The conversation underscores the need for leaders to connect with the lived experiences of ordinary people to foster genuine solutions.
Exploring Obama's Political Legacy
A critique of Barack Obama's recent comments on democracy and pluralism opens a discussion about his presidency and its repercussions. The podcast expresses skepticism about Obama's narrative that overlooks the systemic inequities that still persist, indicating that his ideals often failed to challenge deeply rooted societal structures. As Obama advocates for civil discourse and engagement, the hosts question whether this rhetoric truly addresses the concerns of marginalized groups. The discussion pushes for a more nuanced understanding of how leadership can fall short in creating systemic changes and addressing inequities.
The Role of Opposition and Resistance
The podcast stresses the importance of recognizing resistance as a core aspect of societal growth and political change. The recurring theme of opposition within movements suggests that those seeking change must grapple with entrenched systems that perpetuate inequity. The hosts discuss how marginalized groups often experience their struggles as sacrifices made in the pursuit of justice and equity. This acknowledgment of resistance parallels historical struggles and reinforces the notion that political change requires ongoing engagement, dialogue, and a willingness to confront uncomfortable truths.
Jordan Peterson's New Theories
In discussing Jordan Peterson's latest book, the podcast highlights how he grapples with themes of truth and morality, often evoking responses from those who challenge his perspectives. Peterson's view at times resembles a resignation about societal change, falling back on archetypal narratives instead of substantive solutions. The hosts argue that his idealized perspectives often ignore daily realities faced by individuals, missing a critical understanding of societal structures. This analysis suggests a growing divide between philosophical discussions of morality and the tangible impact of political policies on people's lives.
The Dangers of Simplistic Narratives
The podcast cautions against overly simplistic narratives that cross ideological lines, asserting that such approaches can harm meaningful discourse. The hosts critique how figures like Peterson reduce complex societal issues to individual morality plays or archetypal struggles, diminishing the nuanced understanding required in social justice discussions. They argue that this simplification can breed resentment and misunderstanding rather than fostering empathy or real change. Addressing these narratives head-on is essential in moving towards a more inclusive and compassionate dialogue surrounding political and social issues.
A Call for Structural Change
Finally, the podcast concludes with a call for structural change within economic and political systems to create a more equitable society. The hosts reflect on how personal or anecdotal experiences, while valid, are insufficient in establishing lasting change unless they prompt calls for reform of systemic injustices. An emphasis is placed on collective efforts to address the root causes of inequality as a means of reimagining societal norms and ideals. In doing so, the conversation hopes to inspire hope and action aimed at transforming current frameworks surrounding health care, public welfare, and political accountability.
In our last episode before this year's season break, Matt McManus & Robert Myles join Ben Burgis to break down Jordan Peterson's new book "We Who Wrestle with God." (He doesn't seem to have read any more Marx since 2019.) Before that, Ben and the crew take a look at Ben's article at MSNBC about Obama and the various responses it's provoked--a disdainful sniff from uber-popular historian Heather Cox Richardson on her Substack, what can only be described as a right-populist haiku from Steve Bannon, and a whole lot of unhinged reactions from grassroots libs. In the postgame we're joined by Deep State Kuba for a last bit of non-"We Who Wrestle..." JBP-bashing before we hit the road.
Become a GTAA Patron and receive numerous benefits ranging from patron-exclusive postgames every Monday night to our undying love and gratitude for helping us keep this thing going:
patreon.com/benburgis
Read the weekly philosophy Substack:
benburgis.substack.com
Get the Snipd podcast app
Unlock the knowledge in podcasts with the podcast player of the future.
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode
Save any moment
Hear something you like? Tap your headphones to save it with AI-generated key takeaways
Share & Export
Send highlights to Twitter, WhatsApp or export them to Notion, Readwise & more
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode
