How can Europe defend itself without the United States?
Feb 18, 2025
auto_awesome
James Landale, a BBC Diplomatic Correspondent, dives into Europe's security landscape amid shifting U.S. defense commitments. He details how rising tensions with Russia force European leaders to reconsider their reliance on American military support. They explore historical ties like NATO, current disparities in military spending, and the potential for a unified European defense strategy. Landale also discusses the cultural attitudes toward military service that complicate defense autonomy, painting a complex picture of Europe's security future.
European leaders are facing the challenge of enhancing defense responsibilities in light of potential U.S. withdrawal from traditional security commitments.
The discussion highlights Europe's need for strategic reform to improve military readiness and collective defense amidst rising threats, particularly from Russia.
Deep dives
The Historical Role of NATO
NATO emerged after World War II as a vital alliance between the United States and Europe, instigated by the need for security against the Soviet Union. Following a period of devastation in Europe, the alliance provided both military support and economic assistance through initiatives like the Marshall Plan. The principle behind NATO was that the security of Europe directly correlated with American security, leading to significant military deployments and nuclear capabilities in Europe. This arrangement facilitated a relatively peaceful Europe for decades, largely deterring large-scale conflicts due to the collective defense clause that an attack on one member would be considered an attack on all.
Shifts in Defense Responsibility
Recent geopolitical dynamics have prompted the United States to signal that Europe must enhance its defense responsibilities, reflecting a shift in priorities away from traditional commitments. The end of the Cold War led many European nations to reduce defense spending, believing the threat level had diminished. However, the emergence of new threats, particularly from Russia, alongside U.S. concerns regarding China, has intensified calls for Europe to reassess its military readiness and expenditures. This has ignited discussions among European leaders about recalibrating defense strategies, including the necessity of increasing military budgets and forming cohesive military alliances.
Challenges in European Defense Cooperation
Europe faces significant hurdles in organizing an effective collective defense strategy, particularly regarding manpower and military procurement. Many European nations currently maintain low troop levels and lack sufficient artillery production capabilities, leading to a dependence on American support for resupply during conflicts. Additionally, the idea of a unified European military force faces resistance from within member states, illustrating challenges in achieving collaborative defense capabilities. The necessity for strategic reform emphasizes the importance of cooperation to eliminate redundancies and improve defense spending efficiency across the continent.
With the Trump administration threatening to redirect America's foreign defence spending from Ukraine and Europe to other parts of the world, European leaders are grappling with what the future of their security could be without US support.
Jonny Dymond is joined by the BBC's diplomatic correspondent James Landale. They discuss the threat of Russia and how Europe could defend its borders if the United States were to withdraw its money and manpower from the continent.
The Global Story brings you trusted insights from BBC journalists worldwide. We want your ideas, stories and experiences to help us understand and tell #TheGlobalStory. Email us at theglobalstory@bbc.com You can also message us or leave a voice note via WhatsApp on +44 330 123 9480.
Producers: Alice Aylett Roberts, Eleanor Sly and Laurie Kalus
Sound engineer: Gareth Jones
Assistant editor: Sergi Forcada Freixas
Senior news editor: China Collins
Get the Snipd podcast app
Unlock the knowledge in podcasts with the podcast player of the future.
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode
Save any moment
Hear something you like? Tap your headphones to save it with AI-generated key takeaways
Share & Export
Send highlights to Twitter, WhatsApp or export them to Notion, Readwise & more
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode