The Pat Kenny Show A new documentary 'First Conviction' a quest for justice
Nov 12, 2025
Pamela Fraher, a reporter with RTÉ Investigates, dives into the harrowing case of a couple wrongfully convicted of FGM. She reveals shocking details about the initial medical misdiagnosis and issues with courtroom interpretation that played a critical role in their conviction. Solicitor James McGuill discusses the challenges of their appeal and the importance of new medical evidence that eventually led to a quashed conviction. Together, they highlight systemic flaws in interpreter regulation and the quest for justice that continues as the couple seeks to clear their names.
AI Snips
Chapters
Transcript
Episode notes
Bleeding Toddler Taken To Hospital
- The toddler bled after being frightened by a toy and was taken to Crumlin Hospital where wounds were cauterised.
- Parents insisted on an accidental fall and brought the toy, but doctors raised a non-accidental-injury (NAI) red flag.
Mother Had Been A Victim Of FGM
- The mother had herself experienced FGM and fled that practice; she told Pamela it was horrific and she would never want it for her daughter.
- Despite this, she was later accused of performing FGM on her own child.
Expert Diagnosis Based Solely On Images
- Crumlin sent colposcopy images to UK expert Dr. Deborah Hodes who diagnosed FGM without examining the child.
- That remote diagnosis became central to the prosecution despite no physical examination.