The Pillar Podcast Ep. 236: Blacklisted, and the horse race
Nov 7, 2025
JD and Ed dive into the upcoming U.S. bishops' meeting, dishing on election strategies and candidate eligibility. They share stories of JD's surprising detention at a Chicago event and Cardinal Cupich's COVID response. The duo breaks down the 'horse race' for committee leadership spots, analyzing key candidates for roles in Canonical Affairs, Evangelization, and Protection of Children and Young People. With lively debates on charisma versus expertise, they keep the stakes high in the world of Catholic leadership.
AI Snips
Chapters
Transcript
Episode notes
Detained At A Church Benefit
- JD Flynn and Ed Condon were detained at the Chicago Keep Hope Alive benefit entrance despite having tickets.
- The Archdiocese of Chicago had circulated Flynn's photo to security, creating an awkward but polite confrontation.
Dialogue Over Polarization
- JD Flynn and Ed Condon propose genuine dialogue between bishops and young Catholics as a remedy for polarization.
- They suggest hosting a 'synodality tour' of conversations to include unheard Catholic voices and ecclesiastical leaders.
Elections And Closed Sessions
- The USCCB will vote for new leadership quickly at the fall meeting, including president and vice president.
- Much substantive discussion has moved to executive sessions, reducing public theatre but concentrating decision-making behind closed doors.