Intelligence Squared

The Sunday Debate: If You Believe You are a Citizen of the World, You are a Citizen of Nowhere

Aug 7, 2022
The discussion features David Goodhart, a demographer and author; Elif Shafak, a celebrated Turkish novelist; Simon Schama, a renowned historian; and former diplomat David Landsman. They dive into the tension between national and global identities, sparked by Theresa May's remarks on citizenship. Key topics include the complexities of belonging in a connected world, evolving views on immigration and national identity, and the impact of rising nationalism. The panel advocates for a nuanced understanding of citizenship amid today's societal challenges.
Ask episode
AI Snips
Chapters
Books
Transcript
Episode notes
INSIGHT

Citizenship and the State

  • Theresa May's "citizen of nowhere" quote highlighted the importance of nation-states.
  • Citizenship requires a state, and our freedoms and welfare depend on strong nations.
INSIGHT

Nationalism and Emotion

  • National identity appeals to our emotions and visceral sensations, like football supporters.
  • Tone-deafness to this emotional aspect contributed to Brexit and Trump's election.
ANECDOTE

Plutarch on Belonging

  • Plutarch argued that belonging comes from the mutual relationship between a person and a place.
  • London's diverse leadership demonstrates that embracing different cultures doesn't end a nation.
Get the Snipd Podcast app to discover more snips from this episode
Get the app