Renée DiResta, a scholar specializing in online information campaigns, shares her insights on the politicization of justice in the U.S. She recounts her personal experience battling false accusations accepted by courts without proper investigation. The conversation touches on the troubling parallels between authoritarian regimes and current American legal practices, especially regarding misinformation tied to elections. DiResta emphasizes the implications of recent Supreme Court decisions on public trust and the fragility of judicial independence in democratic societies.
The erosion of judicial independence in the U.S. raises concerns that political affiliations may influence judges' impartiality and fairness.
Misinformation, primarily propagated by domestic actors, poses a serious threat to democratic integrity and can manipulate public perception of justice.
Deep dives
Rule of Law vs. Political Manipulation
The concept of rule of law defines a system where laws operate independently of political interference, ensuring that justice is meted out fairly through courts and legal processes. In stark contrast, authoritarian regimes utilize legal frameworks to protect the ruling elite and suppress dissent, often resulting in fabricated charges against political opponents. An example highlighted is the case of a journalist accused of spreading false information about the Russian military, illustrating how accusations serve to maintain political power rather than seek truth. This underscores a fundamental difference where law is used as a tool for oppression rather than a means of justice.
Misinformation and Democracy
The rise of misinformation, especially surrounding elections, poses a significant threat to democratic integrity. A collaborative effort called the Election Integrity Partnership was initiated to study false claims related to voting procedures, revealing that the primary sources of misinformation were domestic influencers rather than foreign actors. Despite analyzing 22 million tweets, the findings were manipulated by individuals like Mike Benz to suggest a widespread government censorship narrative, stirring controversy and leading to misguided congressional hearings. This illustrates how misinformation can be weaponized within political discourse, impacting perceived democratic processes.
The Erosion of Judicial Independence
Concerns about the politicization of the judiciary are growing, with individuals suggesting that some judges may prioritize political allegiance over impartiality in their rulings. A specific example involves Judge Eileen Cannon, whose handling of a classified documents case involving a former president raised alarms about fairness in the judicial system. As judges may feel compelled to align with political figures to further their careers, the independence of the judiciary could be compromised, leading to a legal system that mirrors non-democratic practices. This scenario presents a critical risk where legal outcomes could favor political allies, undermining the foundational principle of equal justice under the law.
In authoritarian states, the public has no agency and no real access to justice. Renée DiResta, a scholar who researches online information campaigns, struggled to counter false accusations leveled against her after a series of courts accepted them without investigation. As courts become more political, people could begin to assume justice is impossible.
Autocracy in America is produced by The Atlantic and made possible with support from the SNF Agora Institute at Johns Hopkins University, an academic and public forum dedicated to strengthening global democracy through powerful civic engagement and informed, inclusive dialogue.
Music by Howard Harper-Barnes (“Mysterious Forest”), J. F. Gloss (“Mysterious Figures”), Luella Gren (“Sleep Forever”), Farrell Wooten (“Magnified XY”), Ludvig Moulin (“Bats and Rats”), and Rob Smierciak (“Mystery March”).
Get more from your favorite Atlantic voices when you subscribe. You’ll enjoy unlimited access to Pulitzer-winning journalism, from clear-eyed analysis and insight on breaking news to fascinating explorations of our world. Subscribe today at TheAtlantic.com/podsub.