In this podcast, they delve into the complexities of human behavior, the Bayesian brain hypothesis, and the evolution of human communication systems. They explore collective intelligence driving human progress, creativity in language usage, and the unique nature of human language compared to AI systems. The conversation also touches on the shift in concerns regarding AI evolution, from fears of AGI to mimetic intelligence and the implications for society.
Humans can create communication systems without a common language through gestures and actions.
Deaf children in Nicaragua formed sign languages spontaneously through interaction and signal reuse.
Shared physical environment and experiences shape language evolution and conventions.
When individuals with different languages meet, they develop simplified systems that evolve into fuller languages.
Language evolution involves creativity and dynamic adaptations to specific social and contextual interactions.
Concerns exist about centralized algorithms limiting creativity and diversity in human communication.
Deep dives
Creation of Communicative Signals in Preverbal Interactions
Humans have a unique ability to forge communicative relationships even without a common language. Examples like the interaction between Cook and the indigenous people in Tierra del Fuego showcase how through gestures and actions, mutually interpretable signals are created that lead to successful communication, trade, and collaboration.
Emergence of Language-Like Systems from Charade-Like Play
Through activities like charades, people can generate momentary signals with specific meanings that can be reused and modified. This ability can lead to the development of language-like systems where standardized conventions are formed, sequences are established, and signals become stylized and easily understandable, paving the way for structured communication.
Spontaneous Creation of Sign Languages in Deaf Communities
Observations of deaf children in Nicaragua forming sign languages in orphanages highlight how communication systems, including complex sign languages, can emerge spontaneously through interaction and reuse of communicative signals. This ability reflects the human propensity for creating communicative conventions and adapting them for shared understanding.
Cultural Evolution and Adaptation of Language Conventions
Language conventions evolve through cultural interactions, leading to the adoption of common properties to facilitate communication. Shared physical environment and embodied experiences contribute to the shaping of language systems, with languages adapting to human cognitive capacities and the communicative demands of social interactions. The conventionalization of language over time reflects the maturation and refinement of communicative systems through shared value and usage.
Creation of Language
When individuals with different languages come together, they develop a simplified system dubbed as "pigeon" to communicate. Subsequent generations enhance and transform this pigeon into a fuller language with new structures and patterns. This illustrates the innate human tendency to create rich communication systems naturally.
Collective Intelligence and Language Evolution
Language and culture emerge collectively through human interaction and problem-solving. The incremental advancement of tools and methods while addressing specific issues leads to the development of language. This process reflects a form of collective intelligence where individuals contribute to evolving a complex system without a preconceived design.
Creativity in Language and Communication
Language evolution involves creativity and innovation. The concept of creativity has shifted over time from divine inspiration to a social endeavor recognized through social validation. Creativity manifests in everyday interactions, demonstrating the continuous and innate human capacity for generating novel ideas and expressions.
Language Development and Divergence
Language systems are shaped by practical needs and collective problem-solving. The evolution of languages is dynamic and contingent on specific social and contextual interactions. The analogical reasoning and flexible adaptations in languages convey divergent meanings and patterns, highlighting the nuanced and context-specific nature of language development.
The Challenge of Monolithic Algorithms
Concerns arise from monolithic algorithms potentially limiting creativity and diversity in human communication. Large language models, while impressive in their capabilities, may not replicate true human intelligence or problem-solving abilities effectively. The risk of centralized algorithms constraining creativity and communication diversity presents a cautionary note.
Impact of Language Models on Creativity
While language models like GPT-3 exhibit remarkable abilities, they lack human-like agency and creativity. The expanded capabilities of such models may not translate into transformative changes in human creativity or problem-solving. The centrality of divergent thinking and collective intelligence in human communication remains distinct from the capabilities of large language models.
AI Superintelligence vs. Collective Intelligence
Debates surrounding AI superintelligence focus on the potential risks and impacts of centralized algorithms surpassing human capabilities. However, the innate human capacity for collective problem-solving and creative communication sets apart human intelligence from machine learning models. The emphasis on collaborative and divergent thinking suggests that the future lies in harnessing collective intelligence rather than fearing AI superintelligence.
Language Evolution and Cultural Significance
Language evolution reflects a deep connection to human culture and societal interactions. The openness and adaptability of language structures allow for continuous innovation and evolution. While technology like large language models offer new possibilities, they may not replace the nuanced creativity and problem-solving capabilities inherent in human communication.
Nick Chater is Professor of Behavioural Science at Warwick Business School, who works on rationality and language using a range of theoretical and experimental approaches. We discuss his books The Mind is Flat, and the Language Game.
Please support me on Patreon (this is now my main job!) - https://patreon.com/mlst - Access the private Discord, networking, and early access to content.
