114: Why Budgeting Doesn’t Work (and what to do instead) with Jill Sirianni
Oct 7, 2024
auto_awesome
In a lively conversation with Jill Sirianni, co-host of the Frugal Friends Podcast and co-author of 'Buy What You Love Without Going Broke,' the hosts explore the inefficacy of traditional budgeting, especially for neurodivergent minds. Jill shares insights about the concept of being a 'financial goldfish' and discusses the psychological traps of impulse buying. They advocate for values-based spending and offer practical strategies like conducting a 90-day transaction inventory and creating pauses before purchases to foster mindfulness in financial decisions.
Traditional budgeting methods can feel restrictive for neurodivergent individuals, often leading to feelings of deprivation rather than empowerment.
Understanding the psychological triggers behind impulse buying can help individuals develop more mindful financial strategies that align with their values.
Aligning financial choices with personal values allows individuals to navigate spending in a way that prioritizes both enjoyment and responsibility.
Deep dives
The Importance of Neurodivergent-Friendly Spending
Personal budgeting approaches often fail to resonate with neurodivergent individuals, who may find traditional methods overly restrictive and counterproductive. Many people experience budgeting as a form of deprivation rather than a tool for financial empowerment. This perspective can lead to guilt and shame around spending, as individuals internalize societal narratives that label spending as a moral failing. By reframing financial management to align with personal values rather than prescriptive budgets, individuals can cultivate a more fulfilling and functional approach to their finances that recognizes spending as a necessary skill, not a vice.
Understanding Impulse Spending Triggers
Impulse spending is often driven by various triggers such as emotional states, habitual patterns, and external influences. Factors like stress or social pressures can lead individuals to make purchases that do not align with their intentions or values, often leading to buyer's remorse. Recognizing the factors that contribute to impulse buying can help individuals understand their spending habits better. By identifying emotions and situations that lead to unnecessary purchases, individuals can develop strategies for making more mindful financial decisions that prioritize long-term satisfaction over immediate gratification.
Curiosity and Awareness in Financial Decisions
Building awareness around spending habits is crucial for making informed financial choices. The practice of conducting a transaction inventory encourages individuals to reflect on their spending patterns without the immediate pressure to change. This method promotes self-discovery by asking probing questions about the emotional context of purchases, which can lead to richer insights into values and motivations. Emphasizing curiosity over judgment allows individuals to approach their finances with compassion, fostering a healthier relationship with both money and self-identity.
Navigating Social Influences and Marketing Tactics
Understanding the psychological tactics employed by marketers can empower individuals to make more informed purchasing decisions. Marketing strategies often create urgency and manipulate emotions to encourage spending, leading consumers to feel as though their purchases must happen immediately or risk missing out. Acknowledging these tactics allows individuals to slow down and evaluate their motivations behind purchases more critically. By adopting practices like creating a shopping list and resisting the pressure of sales promotions, consumers can become savvier about their finances and make choices that better reflect their genuine needs and wants.
Tailoring Financial Decisions to Personal Values
Aligning financial choices with personal values enables individuals to address their spending in a way that honors their unique life circumstances. Shifting focus from the guilt of perceived indulgences to recognizing the value in convenience can lead to a more fulfilling financial experience. For some, like parents balancing work-life with family needs, spending on time-saving options becomes a worthwhile investment in relationships and overall well-being. By prioritizing genuine values over societal expectations, individuals can navigate their financial decisions through an empowered lens, allowing for both enjoyment and financial responsibility.
I have an honest confession to make. I am a terrible budgeter, but I’m a world-class financial goldfish. In this episode, I’ll explain my “financial goldfish” status and budgeting for our neurodiverse brains. I’m joined by Jill Sirianni, host of the Frugal Friends Podcast. If you’re like me, and budgeting just doesn’t work for you, you’ll learn a lot from our conversation. Join us!
Show Highlights:
Characteristics of a financial goldfish
Budgets–the diet of the financial landscape (and they don’t work any more than diets do for most people)
Top reasons we fall victim to impulse buying
The myth of “Wants vs. Needs”
The downfalls of typical antiquated budgeting
Creativity in meeting needs without spending
Jill’s 90-day transaction inventory
Helpful online tools
A moral problem vs. a systemic problem
KC’s helpful hack to be more thoughtful before spending impulsively (like late-night DoorDash)
Jill’s tips for creating a pause before spending: keep a list and buy second-hand
Understanding the marketing behind sales
Making choices about your behavior today that may not align with spending habits held up as the “standard”
We love the sponsors that make this show possible! You can always find all the special deals and codes for all our current sponsors on our website:www.strugglecare.com/promo-codes.
