Buck Hartzell, a Motley Fool analyst focused on bottom-up investing, discusses the complexities of GDP growth and its lack of correlation with shareholder returns, particularly outside the U.S. Alicia Alfiere, a senior analyst with expertise in Bumble, explores the dating app's pivot towards platonic friendships. The conversation covers the recent surge in China's stock market, the dynamics of consumer versus government-driven economies, and the challenges facing Bumble in expanding its user base amid a competitive landscape.
High GDP growth does not guarantee corresponding stock market returns, highlighting the disconnect between economic performance and investor gains.
Investors are advised to explore small-cap stocks like D-Local, which may offer better valuation and growth potential in uncertain markets.
Deep dives
China's Market Surge and Cautionary Signals
China's stock market experienced a significant surge, with the Shanghai Composite Index increasing over 20% in just the last two weeks of September, reflecting a temporary recovery. Despite this short-term gain, the long-term outlook remains cautious, given that the market has only appreciated around 6% over the past three years. Government actions, such as fiscal stimulus announcements, have contributed to this recent upswing, signaling their intent to bolster the economy and stock market. However, this reliance on government intervention poses risks, as a government-driven economy may not mimic the efficiency found in a consumer-driven market like the United States.
Challenges of Investing in China
Investing in China presents multiple challenges for U.S. investors, primarily due to the legal structure surrounding foreign ownership of Chinese companies, which is often facilitated through complex entities that can obscure true ownership rights. Additionally, the regulatory environment in China is inconsistent and may change abruptly, impacting investor confidence and market stability. The government's control over the economy often leads to unpredictable outcomes, exemplified by past interventions in major tech companies. Given these risks and a lack of enthusiasm from analysts about significant investments in China, many see the market as largely uninvestable.
Misalignment of Growth and Market Returns
There is a paradox where countries experiencing high GDP growth often yield poor stock market returns, as evidenced by research indicating that investors may overvalue growth potential without considering the underlying economic fundamentals. This misalignment also extends to individual stocks, where high growth rates do not necessarily translate into strong investment returns. The dot-com bubble and the subsequent stagnation of many tech stocks serve as historical examples of this trend, highlighting how inflated valuations can lead to prolonged periods of underperformance. Investors are reminded that price matters significantly—great companies can underperform if purchased at inflated prices.
Opportunities in Small-Cap Stocks
Amid uncertain international markets, small-cap stocks are gaining attention for their potential undervalued status, especially following recent rate cuts which historically benefit these companies. The suggestion is for investors to explore small-cap opportunities, as these stocks may be less priced than large caps for the first time in decades. A notable example is D-Local, a small-cap payment service provider with strong fundamentals that has successfully navigated challenging markets. With the potential for strong returns and international exposure, small-cap stocks present an intriguing area for investors looking for growth opportunities.
Some economic measures are indicators for investors, others are red herrings. We unpack why gross domestic product is a sign of economic growth, but not always shareholder returns.
(00:12) Buck Hartzell and Dylan Lewis discuss:
- What’s behind the sudden interest in China’s Shanghai Composite and its 20% run in September.
- Research showing that high GDP growth doesn’t always turn into strong market returns for investors outside the U.S.
- What to look for internationally, and why DLocal is a great small cap to study.
(20:52) Can you find friends on a dating app? Platonic friends, that is. Mary Long caught up with Motley Fool Senior Analyst Alicia Alfiere for a look at Bumble, a dating app company that recently changed a foundational feature and is looking for growth in the friendship market.
Vote here to help Motley Fool Money take home Signal’s Best Money & Finance Show for 2024.