Dateline NBC The Butterfly
Oct 1, 2024
A vibrant young art student's mysterious disappearance sends her community into a panic. The search reveals emotional turmoil and complicated relationships as investigators delve into her past. When skeletal remains are discovered, the case shifts to a homicide investigation, raising suspicions among friends and family. Tensions mount as conflicting alibis and new leads come to light, exposing the fraught dynamics of grief and justice. The relentless pursuit for answers uncovers chilling truths surrounding her tragic fate.
AI Snips
Chapters
Transcript
Episode notes
Caitlin's Disappearance
- Ali Markham was at a festival when her dad called, asking about Caitlin's whereabouts.
- Ali, initially unconcerned, said she hadn't spoken to Caitlin recently but had seen her the morning before.
Initial Investigation
- Caitlin's father, Dave, received a call from Caitlin's fiancé, John Carter, reporting her missing.
- Upon investigating Caitlin's home, Dave found dog poop, suggesting Caitlin's dog had been locked inside for a while.
Friends' Reactions
- Caitlin's friend, Michelle Feist, received a call informing her of Caitlin's disappearance, which was completely out of character.
- Caitlin, described as colorful and quirky, was responsible and would not disappear without reason.