S4E21: Playing to Win—How Student Athletes Get Admitted

In this episode of the Admittedly Podcast, host Thomas Caleel addresses student athletes—and the families supporting them. Whether you're competing at the national level or playing for the love of the game, it’s time to unpack how admissions officers actually view athletics.

Thomas breaks down the value of sports in college admissions, the expectations student athletes must meet, and why athletic ability alone won’t carry you through the process. He offers guidance for both recruited and non-recruited athletes—and reminds listeners that sports are one part of a much bigger admissions picture.

Key Takeaways:

• Athletics Aren’t a Free Pass: No one gets into top schools just for being good at a sport. The strongest athletic applicants have rock-solid academics and clear stories beyond the field.
• Recruited or Not, the Work’s on You: Coaches are building teams, not handing out admissions letters. You need to communicate, self-advocate, and show who you are outside of your sport.
• Go Beyond the Game: Branch out into leadership, service, or mentorship. Coach younger students, join clubs, or connect with causes that matter to you. Being a one-dimensional applicant isn’t enough.
• Think Carefully About That Essay: Injury? Tough loss? Yes, it’s personal—but it’s also common. If you’re writing about sports, make sure your voice and perspective are uniquely yours.
• Whether you're aiming for recruitment or just trying to showcase the full picture of who you are, remember: admissions officers want well-rounded, self-aware students. Sports may be a big part of your life, but they shouldn’t be the only thing that defines you.

Are you balancing sports and academics? Wondering what’s next for your student-athlete journey? DM us your questions on Instagram or TikTok @admittedlyco.

And don’t forget to visit www.admittedly.co for free resources, webinars, and support.