The rise and fall of Major General Ivan Popov unveils a tangled web of corruption in the Russian military. His conviction reveals deeper issues of loyalty and political maneuvering within a hierarchical regime. The podcast dives into the intricate divisions in Russian state politics, highlighting how judicial integrity often succumbs to political agendas. The ripple effects of Popov's case illustrate the Kremlin's fears of powerful military leaders and the troubling shift in military culture from professionalism to allegiance.
49:33
AI Summary
AI Chapters
Episode notes
auto_awesome
Podcast summary created with Snipd AI
Quick takeaways
General Ivan Popov's sentencing highlights the political maneuvering and corruption within the Russian military, showcasing the risks officers face in asserting independence.
The nationalist sentiment surrounding Popov's conviction illustrates a growing divide within Russian society, framing him as a martyr against elite corruption.
Deep dives
Career Trajectory of General Popov
General Ivan Popov's military career exemplifies a steady rise through the ranks of the Russian military, marked by his early aspirations to serve since Soviet times. After graduating from the Moscow Higher Military Command School, he took an active role in the Second Chechen War, which quickly established him as a capable officer. His leadership was noted in varied capacities, including a significant role in the 2008 war against Georgia and subsequent postings that highlighted his strategic capabilities and potential for higher command. As he ascended, he commanded various elite units and demonstrated a knack for turning around struggling brigades, ultimately leading to his appointment as commanding officer of the 58th Combined Arms Army during the ongoing war in Ukraine.
Conflict with Superiors and Subsequent Removal
Despite his successes, Popov faced increasing friction with senior military officials, particularly Chief of General Staff Gerasimov, which stemmed from the combative and competitive nature of military politics under Putinism. In July 2023, he was abruptly removed from command after demanding troop rotations following heavy losses, a move Gerasimov perceived as panic and insubordination. Popov attempted to appeal directly to President Putin, a misstep that further alienated him from powerful commanders exhibiting fear of political reprisals. His vocal criticisms of military leadership in a recorded message, outlining failures and high casualty rates, ultimately solidified his demise within the military hierarchy.
Corruption and Political Dynamics
General Popov's conviction on dubious embezzlement charges highlights the pervasive corruption and political maneuvering within the Russian military system. His case illustrates how operational decisions can lead to politically motivated prosecutions, as his peers, guilty of similar or worse misconduct, escape scrutiny. Local authorities challenging the narrative against Popov and failing to support the prosecution signal fractures within the military establishment reflecting a complex web of loyalties and rivalries. Ultimately, Popov's situation underscores the precarious position of military officers who must navigate a landscape rife with political jealousy and self-preservation.
Emergence as a Symbol of Nationalist Sentiment
The backlash following Popov's sentencing indicates a rise in nationalist sentiment that resonates with certain factions within Russian society, portraying him as a victim of political machinations. Prominent military correspondents expressed their view that his conviction is a disgrace, invoking the idea that his service and patriotism outweighed the charges against him. This perspective frames Popov as a martyr battling against a corrupt elite, thus converting his plight into a point of nationalist rallying. His case has undoubtedly drawn attention to internal military conflicts and sparked discussions about loyalty versus professionalism within the Russian military establishment, underlining the broader challenges facing Putin's regime.
General Ivan Popov, once hailed as one of the heroes and rising stars of the Russian army, has just been sentenced to 5 years in a general regime penal colony on what seem questionable charges. What brought down this 'fighting general' -- and what does it tell us about late Putinism and the potential nationalist critique of the regime?
The sign-up page for the Conducttr info-political wargame I mentioned is here.
The podcast's corporate partner and sponsor is Conducttr, which provides software for innovative and immersive crisis exercises in hybrid warfare, counter-terrorism, civil affairs and similar situations.
You can also follow my blog, In Moscow's Shadows, and become one of the podcast's supporting Patrons and gain question-asking rights and access to exclusive extra materials including the (almost-) weekly Govorit Moskva news briefing right here.
