The Fr. Mike Schmitz Catholic Podcast Fr. Mike Schmitz Reacts to "Wake Up Dead Man: A Knives Out Mystery"
5 snips
Jan 8, 2026 Fr. Mike explores the intriguing portrayal of Catholicism in Hollywood, emphasizing how it often misses the mark. He contrasts the dynamic between a mean older priest and a compassionate young priest in the film. The discussion highlights Father Judd's struggles and his mission of service over conflict, showcasing a poignant moment where he prioritizes prayer over solving mysteries. Surprisingly, mercy emerges as a central theme, prompting Fr. Mike to reflect on how love and forgiveness should guide our actions.
AI Snips
Chapters
Transcript
Episode notes
Catholic Portrayals Often Miss The Mark
- Hollywood usually fumbles faithful Catholic portrayals by making them sound like other Protestant stereotypes.
- Rian Johnson's film offers a rarer, more believable depiction of priests with complex moral character.
Old Priest Vs. Young Priest Contrast
- Fr. Mike contrasts the film's mean old priest with a younger, troubled priest who used to be a boxer.
- The young priest's brokenness and restraint create sympathy rather than rebellion.
Priestly Mission: Heal, Don't Dominate
- Father Judd can fight but chooses not to because his mission is service, not domination.
- The film frames priestly mission as healing and reconciliation, not merely combatting the world.