
#1199 - How One of My Smartest Critics Returned to Faith in God
44 snips
Aug 25, 2026 Joe Schmid, philosopher and creator of the Majesty of Reason channel, recounts his reversion to Catholicism after years of agnosticism. He talks about intellectual shifts from biology to philosophy, contingency and fine-tuning arguments, and how Eucharistic and Lourdes miracles affected his outlook. He also reflects on saints, Padre Pio, and why converging miracles pointed him back to Catholic faith.
AI Snips
Chapters
Books
Transcript
Episode notes
Early Faith Then The First Wobble Over Evolution
- Joe recounts a devout Catholic childhood, K–12 Catholic schooling, daily prayer, and early exposure to apologetics on Catholic radio.
- Evolution in middle school first shook him, prompting him to read Francis Collins and Biologos to reconcile faith and science.
Animal Suffering Sparked Teenage Deconversion
- The evolutionary history's extensive animal suffering pushed Joe from faith toward atheism as a teenager.
- He watched New Atheist debates and felt psychological pulls of intellectual rebellion and contingency arguments.
Contemporary Cosmological Arguments Reopened Theism
- Josh Rasmussen and Alexander Pruss introduced Joe to modal and contingency cosmological arguments that reopened theism as a live option.
- Long email exchanges with Rasmussen and reading Necessary Existence shifted Joe from atheism to agnosticism.













