The Watch

‘Dune’ Was a Box Office Hit, so Why Doesn’t ‘Dune: Prophecy’ Work? Plus, ‘Say Nothing’ With Sean Fennessey.

22 snips
Nov 18, 2024
Sean Fennessey, Head of Content at The Ringer and host of the Big Picture Podcast, joins the conversation to dissect the moral complexity of 'Say Nothing' and the pitfalls of adapting 'Dune: Prophecy' for television. They explore why the prequel series struggles, contrasting it with its cinematic predecessor's success. The discussion shifts to the finale of 'Disclaimer' and the narrative techniques that impact storytelling across mediums. Fennessey’s insights elevate the critique of contemporary adaptations and highlight the nuances of character portrayal in media.
Ask episode
AI Snips
Chapters
Books
Transcript
Episode notes
INSIGHT

Moral Ambiguity in "Say Nothing"

  • Say Nothing succeeds by embracing moral ambiguity in the Troubles.
  • It humanizes individuals, exploring their motivations without clear-cut judgments.
ANECDOTE

UK Critics on "Say Nothing"

  • UK reviewers criticize Say Nothing for sympathizing with terrorists.
  • One reviewer cites personal experience with IRA bombings, acknowledging the show's quality but struggling with its moral stance.
INSIGHT

TV vs. Film in Portraying the Troubles

  • Films about the Troubles often focus on one or two characters and events.
  • Say Nothing, as a TV show, effectively explores the history and multiple characters over a longer period.
Get the Snipd Podcast app to discover more snips from this episode
Get the app