Jay'sAnalysis

Pt 2 RC Horsch 'House of Horrors' & Occult Serial Kill3er Cases, Warren Smith, Utilitarianism Refuted

Sep 26, 2026
From charismatic healing claims and Waldorf’s occult roots to Orthodox ecclesiology, autocephaly, and liturgical worship, this discussion ranges across theology, history, and politics. It also tackles subjective ethics, utilitarianism, elections, Vatican II, AI media, physical books, and the chilling Gary Heidnik “House of Horrors” case.
Ask episode
AI Snips
Chapters
Books
Transcript
Episode notes
INSIGHT

Why Subjective Ethics Cannot Become Universal

  • Jay argues that subjective preferences cannot justify universal moral obligations or explain what “the good” objectively means.
  • He uses immigration, diversity, flourishing, and even domination to expose the missing bridge from personal aims to universal ethics.
ANECDOTE

The Innocent Scapegoat Problem For Utilitarianism

  • Jay presents a utilitarian thought experiment where authorities punish an innocent person to calm society during an unknown serial-killer crisis.
  • The example shows how maximizing collective reassurance can violate justice.
INSIGHT

The Non-Aggression Principle Has A Scope Problem

  • Combining utilitarianism with a non-aggression principle does not define aggression narrowly enough to exclude economic harm.
  • Jay notes that undermining someone’s business could be justified as maximizing public pleasure under the same framework.
Get the Snipd Podcast app to discover more snips from this episode
Get the app