
The Herd with Colin Cowherd Colin Cowherd Podcast - Allen Outduels Mahomes, Dodgers “Best Run” Team In Sports? Caleb Williams Showing Growth, Rams Best In NFC?
Nov 3, 2025
John Middlekauff, a former NFL scout and host of the '3 and Out' podcast, joins to dissect the latest NFL action. They analyze how the Bills' defense effectively pressured Patrick Mahomes, questioning Buffalo's postseason potential. Middlekauff highlights Caleb Williams' growth as he reduces errors in shootouts. They praise Brian Flores' defensive strategy for the Vikings and consider Aaron Rodgers' future. The duo also contrasts the Rams' clarity with the Packers' identity crisis, and they see promise in the Giants' Jaxson Dart.
AI Snips
Chapters
Transcript
Episode notes
Defense Intensity Beats Scheme
- Buffalo's defense raised intensity vs. Patrick Mahomes and disrupted Kansas City's offense.
- Colin sees effort and matchup-specific energy as decisive in that win.
Caleb Williams' Visible Development
- Caleb Williams shows clear growth: fewer turnovers and more big plays.
- Colin values wins that break a long losing culture as meaningful progress.
Context Matters For Young QBs
- J.J. McCarthy benefits from elite supporting pieces and situational coaching.
- Colin wants more tape before fully evaluating McCarthy's standalone ceiling.

