192. The Murder of Peggy Carr -- That Girl is Poison
May 23, 2023
auto_awesome
The podcast explores the mysterious case of Peggy Carr's murder, discussing her troubled marriage, whirlwind romance, and strange threats. They also delve into tampered Coke bottles and the Tylenol poisonings, suspecting Peggy's husband as the guilty party. The investigation involves Mensa and talium poisoning, shedding light on the twists and turns of the case.
The importance of securing homes and being cautious of unexpected items to prevent poisoning.
The bravery and determination of Detective Susan Goric in her undercover role, contributing significantly to the investigation.
The meticulous planning and execution of George Trepel, the mastermind behind Peggy Carr's poisoning.
Deep dives
Peggy Carr's Mysterious Illness and Death
In this podcast episode, the hosts discuss the case of Peggy Carr, a woman who fell ill with severe pain and symptoms that doctors could not diagnose. Eventually, it was discovered that Peggy had been poisoned with thallium, a banned substance, and her illness had escalated rapidly. The police and FBI investigate the case, and suspicion falls on George Trepel, a neighbor who had a dispute with Peggy and had the knowledge and means to commit the crime. Evidence found in his home, including thallium and chemical textbooks, points to his involvement. The hosts explore the method used to poison Peggy, highlighting the importance of locking doors and being cautious of unexpected items in the home.
Susan Goric's Undercover Investigation
Detective Susan Goric from the Polk County Sheriff's Office goes undercover to investigate George Trepel, the suspected murderer. Susan befriends George, who is obsessed with creating the perfect murders and grills him on poisons and how crimes could be committed. She even rents the house next to Peggy Carr's, where George used to live, and searches for evidence. This leads to the discovery of thallium and other incriminating items in George's home, connecting him to Peggy's poisoning. The hosts highlight Susan's bravery and determination in her undercover role, emphasizing the importance of her contributions to the investigation.
The Intricate Plot by George Trepel
George Trepel, a chemist and Mensa member, was discovered to be the mastermind behind Peggy Carr's poisoning. He had a deep-seated animosity towards Peggy and her family, leading to his plan to poison her. George lured Peggy's family by placing an eight-pack of Coke, filled with thallium, in their pantry. Because the family didn't lock their doors, George was able to sneak into their home and carry out his scheme. Peggy's severe illness and subsequent death exposed George's carefully crafted plan, showcasing the meticulous nature of his criminal activity.
The Mystery of Peggy's Poisoning
Peggy, a woman who was poisoned with thallium, fell into a coma and eventually died. The main suspect was her husband Pie, who had access to chemicals at the mine he worked in. However, the police found evidence that the thallium was delivered through an eight-pack of bottled cokes. Most of the bottles had been consumed, and one tested positive for a high amount of thallium. Despite suspicion falling on Pie, he tested positive for thallium as well, making it unlikely that he poisoned himself and his son intentionally. The investigation led to the discovery of the smart neighbor's involvement.
The Role of the Minsa Society
Susan Gorick, who infiltrated the Minsa society, played a crucial role in solving the mystery. The local Minsa group held a murder mystery event at a local inn, and Susan expressed her interest in participating. It was later revealed that one of the suspects, a neighbor obsessed with killing people, had been living in the victim's basement and stealing their food. While the husband, George, was arrested and convicted of the poisoning, his wife was not implicated due to insufficient evidence. Susan Gorick's undercover work and subsequent book about the case shed light on this remarkable story.
