Sophie Gilbert, an Atlantic staff writer and author of 'Girl on Girl,' dives into the complex relationship between feminism and pop culture. She discusses how the shift from 90s riot grrrl activism to the superficial 'girl power' of the Spice Girls contributed to the postfeminist landscape. Gilbert analyzes the role of internet pornography in shaping societal attitudes and the clash between empowerment and exploitation. She advocates for a nuanced understanding of feminism that prioritizes collective action over individualism.
The transition from the riot grrrl movement to post-feminism illustrates how media and commercial culture diluted genuine feminist activism into consumer-based empowerment.
The rise of internet pornography reshaped societal standards of female sexuality, highlighting the need for a renewed feminist focus on collective empowerment and diverse narratives.
Deep dives
The Evolution of Feminism: From Riot Grrrl to Spice Girls
Feminism in the late 90s transitioned dramatically from the riot grrrl movement's fierce activism to a more celebratory post-feminism, epitomized by the Spice Girls' 'girl power' slogan. The riot grrrl movement, which focused on empowerment and safety for women, gradually gave way to a diluted version of feminism that celebrated consumerism and superficial empowerment without advocating for real change. This shift indicated a cultural transformation influenced by the emergence of mainstream media and pop culture, where messages of female empowerment became less about activism and more about personal freedom to consume and express oneself. The commercialization of 'girl power' signified that while women were told they were free to choose, the choices often reverted to purchasing and lifestyle branding rather than societal equity.
Cultural Shifts and the Influence of Sexuality
The podcast discusses how the AIDS crisis significantly impacted cultural attitudes towards sex, leading to a movement that celebrated sexual expression even amidst a backdrop of anxiety and fear. Figures like Madonna exemplified this new sex positivity, where sexual celebration became a way to counteract prevailing fears, thus permeating various aspects of media and pop culture. As the 90s unfolded, sexual imagery became pervasive, ultimately prompting a societal trend that framed sexual power as the main form of empowerment for women. However, this hyper-sexualized narrative arguably restricted the broader scope of women's empowerment, often reducing their identity to mere sexual presentation.
The Role of Technology in Shaping Modern Feminism
The explosion of technology, especially with the rise of the internet and digital cameras, is highlighted as a crucial factor that transformed cultural perceptions and experiences of women. The proliferation of accessible pornography and the significant uptick in its consumption shifted the landscape, influencing societal standards around female sexuality and desirability. The discussion highlights the tension between the empowering potential of technology for self-expression and the exploitative aspects that often accompany it. Ultimately, while technological advancements have enabled diverse voices to emerge, they have also perpetuated narrow definitions and expectations surrounding women's identities.
Redefining Feminism and Collective Power
The podcast argues for a renewed focus within feminism that embraces collective empowerment rather than individualism, which has historically dominated recent narratives. It emphasizes the importance of storytelling in redefining women’s experiences, advocating for narratives that celebrate not just individual successes, but collective efforts towards change. Despite acknowledging the valuable strides made in visibility for women of various ages, there remains a concern that visibility is often contingent on maintaining traditional beauty standards. Ultimately, the call is for feminism to encompass a broader spectrum of empowerment that includes women’s ambitions in all facets of life, moving beyond consumerism and superficiality.
The ’90s are sometimes described as the beginning of the postfeminist era. But if feminism died 30 years ago, who killed it? The Atlantic staff writer Sophie Gilbert seeks to answer this question in her new book, Girl on Girl,and finds a likely suspect in the contemporaneous rise of internet pornography.
Get more from your favorite Atlantic voices when you subscribe. You’ll enjoy unlimited access to Pulitzer-winning journalism, from clear-eyed analysis and insight on breaking news to fascinating explorations of our world. Subscribe today at TheAtlantic.com/podsub.
