The Rise and Fall of the Intellectual Dark Web | Guest: Dave Smith | 4/30/25
Apr 30, 2025
auto_awesome
Join comedian and political commentator Dave Smith as he delves into the rise and fall of the Intellectual Dark Web. Known for his libertarian views, Dave discusses how figures like Jordan Peterson and Sam Harris initially championed free speech but have since veered towards calls for censorship. The conversation explores the evolution of political identities, the impact of 'wokeness' on American culture, and the complexities of foreign policy discussions, pushing for a more nuanced dialogue amidst today's turbulent political landscape.
The intellectual dark web, initially a platform for free speech, has shifted towards advocating censorship amid changing ideological stances.
Dave Smith's experiences with deplatforming highlight the growing tensions and challenges of open dialogue in today's polarized discourse.
Reflecting on the political landscape, there's an urgent need for moderates to engage in honest conversations about America's domestic priorities.
Deep dives
Return of Degree Cool Rush
The recent reformulation of Degree Cool Rush deodorant sparked significant backlash among consumers, leading to widespread dissatisfaction and even a petition for the original scent's return. Responding to this feedback, Degree acknowledged the mistake and reinstated the original formula, which is now available at major retailers for under $4. This product's comeback highlights the power of consumer voice in influencing corporate decisions, particularly when a beloved product is altered in ways that do not meet consumer expectations. The nostalgic appeal of the cool, crisp scent is positioned as a triumph for loyal customers who valued its longstanding effectiveness as a men's antiperspirant.
Introduction of Nicole Shanahan
Nicole Shanahan, a prominent attorney and entrepreneur from Silicon Valley, is welcomed to a new media platform, where she will host her show 'Back to the People.' Her background includes advocacy for transparency and government reform, as she has worked on social movements alongside notable figures. Shanahan's personal transformation rooted in her faith informs her approach to exploring underreported issues in the mainstream media. By engaging with experts and everyday citizens, she aims to uncover hidden narratives and promote meaningful discussions on pressing societal topics.
Controversy Surrounding Rogan's Interview
A recent interview on Joe Rogan's podcast generated a substantial online reaction, particularly following a debate between Dave Smith and Douglas Murray. The discussion highlighted the complexities within the intellectual dark web, a loosely connected group known for challenging progressive ideologies. This episode marked a significant moment for Smith, who noted it as one of the most impactful experiences in his career, where heated debates ignited responses across social media. The ongoing developments reflect a growing tension in public discourse, particularly around contentious political ideas and figures.
The Evolution of the Intellectual Dark Web
The concept of the intellectual dark web emerged as a response to perceived problems within progressive circles, positioning itself as a platform for free speech and diverse thought. Early influencers like Jordan Peterson and Sam Harris gained traction by addressing broader societal concerns, yet the movement has reportedly shifted over time amidst internal conflicts and evolving ideologies. Smith reflects critically on the transformation of key figures, noting their varying responses to censorship and public scrutiny. The initial mission to promote open dialogue now faces challenges as these influencers navigate increasingly polarized viewpoints.
Challenges of Contemporary Political Discourse
The current political landscape presents a dilemma where moderates struggle to find their place amid extreme viewpoints, complicating discussions around foreign policy and societal values. As skepticism towards traditional political narratives grows, there's a call for honest conversations that prioritize American interests without being tethered to foreign agendas. Figures from various spectrums of political thought are urged to confront the implications of their advocated policies and the disconnect between public sentiment and elite perspectives. This struggle for balance reflects a broader movement towards re-evaluating commitments to foreign alliances in favor of a more America-focused approach to governance.
When a loosely connected group of disgruntled liberals burst onto the scene to tackle the problem of wokeness, it seemed like a big deal. Men like Jordan Peterson, Sam Harris, and Eric Weinstein found huge audiences while stressing the importance of free speech and open dialogue. But now, a decade after they made their mark, many members of the "intellectual dark web" have changed their tune and are now calling for censorship and deplatforming. Comedian Dave Smith, who has found himself a target of these deplatforming efforts, joins me to discuss.
