In this engaging discussion, Michael Eric Dyson, a noted sociologist, and William Howell, an expert on American politics, argue that the political establishment has failed to serve the needs of the populace. Opposing this view, Jennifer Rubin, a sharp columnist from The Washington Post, and Eric Oliver, a political scientist, defend the establishment's role in maintaining stability. They delve into issues like political accountability, historical roots of inequality, and the necessity for reform in governance. Explore their passionate exchanges and insights on America's political landscape.
01:07:07
forum Ask episode
web_stories AI Snips
view_agenda Chapters
menu_book Books
auto_awesome Transcript
info_circle Episode notes
insights INSIGHT
Political System in Question
The 2017 US political landscape questioned the efficacy of the two-party system.
Many felt the system favored elites, prompting a debate on the political establishment's role.
insights INSIGHT
Establishment's Failure
Michael Eric Dyson argues that the political establishment has failed America.
He criticizes the establishment for neglecting vulnerable populations and prioritizing narrow interests.
question_answer ANECDOTE
"You're Toast"
Eric Oliver shares his wife's prediction that he would be "toast" in the debate.
This anecdote highlights the widespread sentiment of discontent with the political establishment.
Get the Snipd Podcast app to discover more snips from this episode
In 'Tears We Cannot Stop: A Sermon to White America,' Michael Eric Dyson delivers a hard-hitting sermon on the racial divide, directed specifically to a white audience. The book grapples with the social construct of 'whiteness' and challenges readers to face difficult truths about how black grievance has been ignored, dismissed, or discounted. Dyson argues that real racial progress requires honesty about the past, recognition of the present, and collective action to redeem the nation's future. The book is praised for its emotional, literary, and powerful narrative, drawing from Dyson's personal experiences and cultural analysis.
Sign up for Intelligence Squared Premium here: https://iq2premium.supercast.com/ for ad-free listening, bonus content, early access and much more. See below for details.
In this archive debate from 2017 produced in collaboration with the University of Chicago, we asked: has the political establishment failed America? In 2017, the view was that whether they voted for Trump or Sanders or none of the above, millions of Americans felt the answer might be yes – and that the system benefits the elites at the expense of everyone else. While others say that despite its flaws, the political establishment has been a force for unparalleled stability, prosperity and equality – and that it is the only thing standing between America and the abyss. Is it time for the old guard to come to the rescue or to make way for a new political reality? Arguing in favour of the motion were Michael Eric Dyson of Georgetown University and William Howell of UChicago. Arguing against the motion were Jennifer Rubin of the Washington Post and Eric Oliver of UChicago. Our host for this event was Mary Ann Ahern, Political Reporter for NBC5 Chicago.
…
We are incredibly grateful for your support. To become an Intelligence Squared Premium subscriber, follow the link: https://iq2premium.supercast.com/
Here’s a reminder of the benefits you’ll receive as a subscriber:
Ad-free listening, because we know some of you would prefer to listen without interruption
One early episode per week
Two bonus episodes per month
A 25% discount on IQ2+, our exciting streaming service, where you can watch and take part in events live at home and enjoy watching past events on demand and without ads
A 15% discount and priority access to live, in-person events in London, so you won’t miss out on tickets
Intelligence Squared 
