Matthew Cox | Inside True Crime Podcast When The Suspect Outsmarts The The Detective (The Real Story)
Dec 28, 2025
Travis Abney, a former detective with extensive experience in homicide investigations, recounts a gripping case where a suspect remained ahead of law enforcement. He delves into the details of a chilling murder witnessed by children and shares insights on gathering evidence amidst family conspiracies. The conversation also highlights the complexity of another missing person case, revealing the challenges of forensic evidence and community involvement. With a mix of detective stories and techniques, Travis provides a fascinating look into the world of crime-solving.
AI Snips
Chapters
Transcript
Episode notes
Early Ambush Foreshadows Murder
- Travis Abney describes Bobby Caldwell being lured to an abandoned house and ambushed by Sterling Roberts.
- Caldwell escaped that attempt and later reported the threat to Greene County dispatch but the case handling was inadequate.
Murder In Front Of Children
- On August 15, Bobby Caldwell is shot dead in front of his three sons after family counseling.
- The killer wore a hat and glasses and fired at point-blank range, leaving the children traumatized.
Cell Data Breaks Local Limits
- Cellular and surveillance evidence placed Sterling Roberts at key locations after the murder.
- Coordinated federal help (FBI CAST expert Kevin Horan) proved critical to tying movements together.