Intelligence Squared The Perilous Quest Towards Gene Editing, with Matthew Cobb
Nov 30, 2022
Matthew Cobb, a Professor of Zoology at the University of Manchester and author of The Genetic Age, dives into the complex world of gene editing. He discusses the groundbreaking CRISPR technology and its ethical implications, emphasizing the necessity for public engagement. Cobb reflects on notable cases like GM crops and the controversial gene editing in human embryos. With a focus on gene drives in controlling malaria, he raises concerns about informed consent and the risks of heritable editing, urging for responsible discourse on this transformative yet perilous quest.
AI Snips
Chapters
Books
Transcript
Episode notes
Scientists' Narrow Focus
- Scientists often prioritize technical feasibility over ethical considerations and societal impact.
- This can lead to overlooking potential risks and neglecting broader discussions about the implications of scientific advancements.
Asilomar Conference Oversight
- At the 1975 Asilomar conference, scientists focused on lab safety but ignored ethical and societal implications of genetic engineering, including weaponization.
- Ironically, a Russian delegation present, initially dismissed by Americans, had already initiated a bioweapons program using genetic engineering.
Informed Consent Challenges
- Achieving truly informed consent for technologies with widespread consequences is nearly impossible.
- The complexity of genetics and the potential for global spread make it difficult for individuals to fully comprehend the implications and make informed decisions.
