Carl Robichaud, co-leader of Longview Philanthropy’s nuclear weapons policy program, dives deep into the looming threat of nuclear war. He reflects on the morality of the bombings at Hiroshima and Nagasaki, and critiques the lessons learned from the Cuban Missile Crisis. The conversation touches on modern challenges like cyber vulnerabilities and escalating U.S.-China tensions, along with the role of private citizens in mitigating nuclear risks. Robichaud emphasizes the need for philanthropy in addressing these existential threats, blending urgency with hope.
The podcast explores the ongoing threat of nuclear war and discusses topics such as the ethics of dropping atomic bombs, the history and future of nuclear proliferation, and cyber vulnerabilities.
The podcast highlights the increased risk of nuclear escalation due to recent events, particularly Russia's invasion of Ukraine, and the expanding nuclear arsenal of China.
The podcast emphasizes the importance of maintaining the nuclear taboo, assessing cyber vulnerabilities, and explores the role of private citizens in mitigating nuclear risk.
Deep dives
The Threat of Nuclear War
The podcast episode explores the ongoing threat of nuclear war and discusses various aspects related to nuclear weapons, including the ethical questions surrounding the use of atomic bombs on Hiroshima and Nagasaki, the Cuban Missile Crisis, and the false lessons learned from it. The episode also delves into the history and future of nuclear proliferation, the logic of deterrence, vulnerabilities to cyber attacks, the history of de-escalation, tensions between the US and China, the role of artificial intelligence, and the importance of private citizens in mitigating nuclear risk.
The Ongoing Challenge of Nuclear Proliferation
Despite the success of international efforts in limiting nuclear weapons, the podcast highlights Iran as a country that may be on the verge of acquiring nuclear weapons. This potential acquisition could lead to other regional powers seeking nuclear armament, such as Saudi Arabia. The importance of US security assurances and norms against nuclear weapons proliferation in preventing further spread is emphasized.
Escalating Nuclear Risk in Current Geopolitical Dynamics
The episode stresses the increased risk of nuclear escalation due to recent events, particularly Russia's invasion of Ukraine. While Russia has made veiled threats involving nuclear weapons, the response from the US and NATO has been cautious and measured, focusing on conventional military actions rather than invoking nuclear weapons. The complex dynamics in the region involve considerations beyond military actions, including international reputation and deterrence. However, the escalating risk of nuclear proliferation is also highlighted in light of China's substantial nuclear arsenal expansion.
Preserving the Nuclear Taboo and Controlling Nuclear Risk
The podcast emphasizes the importance of maintaining the nuclear taboo and the role it plays in preventing nuclear weapon use. It highlights the potential consequences if a country were to cross the nuclear threshold, including potential waves of interest in nuclear weapons or a rejection of their use. The discussion highlights the need to work towards building upon past successes in non-proliferation efforts, as well as the dangers of cyber vulnerabilities in nuclear systems and the importance of continually assessing and mitigating risks associated with nuclear weapons.
The Fragility of Norms and the Contradictions of Nuclear Weapons
The podcast discusses the fragility of norms and the contradictions surrounding nuclear weapons. It highlights the importance of norms in preventing the use of certain weapons and the danger of crossing those lines. The podcast also explores the contrasting attitudes towards banning other weapons that cause significant harm to civilians, compared to the existence and use of nuclear weapons. It raises concerns about the growing tensions between the US and China, particularly regarding their commitment to protecting Taiwan. The podcast emphasizes the need for collective efforts to mitigate the risk of nuclear weapons and calls for increased attention, funding, and voices from society to address this critical issue.
The Role of Philanthropy and Paths to Create Meaningful Change
The podcast highlights the opportunities for philanthropy and the role of private citizens in addressing the risks posed by nuclear weapons. It emphasizes the historical significance of non-governmental voices in changing government policies and increasing public awareness. The podcast discusses the need for financial support and collaboration with organizations dedicated to reducing nuclear risks. It acknowledges the lack of funding in this area and encourages individuals to donate and engage in political discourse. The podcast also suggests various career paths, including government service, academia, arts, media, and civil society, as ways to contribute meaningfully to nuclear weapons risk reduction efforts.
Sam Harris speaks with Carl Robichaud about the ongoing threat of nuclear war. They discuss the film "Oppenheimer," the ethics of dropping atomic bombs on Hiroshima and Nagasaki, the false lessons of the Cuban Missile Crisis, the history and future of nuclear proliferation, the logic of deterrence, cyber vulnerabilities, the history of de-escalation, the war in Ukraine, war games, the nuclear taboo, growing tensions between the U.S. and China, artificial intelligence, getting to nuclear zero, the role for private citizens in mitigating nuclear risk, the Longview Nuclear Risk Policy Fund (https://www.longview.org/fund/nuclear-weapons-policy-fund/), and other topics.
If the Making Sense podcast logo in your player is BLACK, you can SUBSCRIBE to gain access to all full-length episodes at samharris.org/subscribe.
Learning how to train your mind is the single greatest investment you can make in life. That’s why Sam Harris created the Waking Up app. From rational mindfulness practice to lessons on some of life’s most important topics, join Sam as he demystifies the practice of meditation and explores the theory behind it.
Remember Everything You Learn from Podcasts
Save insights instantly, chat with episodes, and build lasting knowledge - all powered by AI.
