Gary Younge, a journalist and academic, teams up with historian David Edgerton to dissect the cultural significance of Steve McQueen's film, Blitz. They delve into Britain's obsession with WWII narratives and how these shape national identity and politics today. The conversation touches on the evolving portrayal of race and class during the war, critiques the isolationist 'Alone' narrative, and explores how wartime memories influence current events like Brexit. Their insights reveal a complex interplay between history and modern British society.
The film 'Blitz' challenges traditional war narratives by highlighting the nuanced home front experiences of race, gender, and class during WWII.
The glorification of the 'blitz spirit' in contemporary politics often oversimplifies complex social dynamics and misrepresents historical realities.
Deep dives
The Impact of War films in British Culture
War films hold a significant place in British culture as they shape societal understanding and memory of historical events. The discussion highlights that these films often focus on themes of action and heroism, primarily featuring narratives about white male characters in combat. This trend reflects a collective cultural memory where the wars symbolize moments of national identity and heroism, causing lesser-known historical themes, such as colonialism and race, to be overshadowed. Notable films like 'Dunkirk' and '1917' contribute to this narrative, influencing both public perception and political discourse in contemporary Britain.
Blitz: A Home Front Perspective
The film 'Blitz' offers a unique perspective by centering on the home front experience during the German bombing raids, shifting the focus from traditional battlefield narratives. It explores the intricate social dynamics of London during the blitz, revealing issues of race, gender, and class that persisted despite the large-scale destruction. Through the characters, particularly a mixed-race boy and his mother, the film illustrates how different groups experienced solidarity and tension simultaneously, showcasing the complexity of social relations during wartime. This portrayal challenges the simplistic notion of a unified national front, emphasizing that fissures in society did not vanish under the pressures of war.
The Politics of War Narratives
Recent political discourses have increasingly invoked war metaphors to frame contemporary issues, from Brexit to the COVID-19 pandemic. Politicians have drawn parallels between the challenges faced today and those during World War II, often romanticizing the idea of national resilience. This narrative has sparked criticism, particularly regarding the misrepresentation of wartime experiences and the oversimplification of complex social dynamics. An analysis reveals how the glorification of the 'blitz spirit' can obscure the realities of war, which included scarcity and hardship, ultimately reflecting a recurrent theme in political rhetoric that seeks to invoke a sense of unity and resilience that may not align with historical truths.
A new film from Steve McQueen is about to hit cinema screens: Blitz. Set during the devastating German bombing raids of 1940 to 1941, it follows Saiorse Ronan as east end mum Rita, and her son George, played by Elliot Heffernan, as they travel across London searching for each other.
In some ways, it’s a new look at history, Rita’s son is mixed race – and issues of race, class, and gender are present throughout McQueen’s film.
But Blitz also takes its place in a long tradition: almost 80 years on from the end of the Second World War, Britain’s role in both world wars still dominates British culture and retains a central place in our national psyche, and our politics. Why is this?
Tom Gatti is joined by journalist and academic Gary Younge and historian David Edgerton.
Get access to all our reporting at newstatesman.com and receive your copy of our weekly magazine. Podcast listeners can get the first two months for just £2 at https://www.newstatesman.com/save