Americano Why is the American right arguing about property tax?
Nov 19, 2025
Blake Neff, a conservative commentator and former contributor for The Spectator, joins the discussion on the divisive topic of property tax within the American right. He argues against abolishing property tax, citing its benefits over income taxes for funding public services. Explore how generational dynamics play a role, as eliminating property taxes favors older citizens but can burden younger generations. Delve into real-world examples from Florida, California, and Texas, highlighting the intricate balance between tax incentives and housing affordability.
AI Snips
Chapters
Transcript
Episode notes
Property Tax Beats Steeper Alternatives
- Abolishing property tax would likely shift the burden onto younger people via higher income or sales taxes.
- Blake Neff argues property taxes distort less and protect affordability better than steep sales or income taxes.
Abolition Favors Older, Wealthier Voters
- Abolishing property tax skews benefits toward older Americans who already hold more wealth.
- Neff warns the policy would intensify generational inequality and harm younger people trying to buy homes and start families.
Short-Term Wins, Long-Term Political Risk
- 'Boomer populism' that targets older voters can win short-term elections due to demographics.
- Neff warns it risks long-term political damage by alienating younger voters who will form the future electorate.