In this live episode at Norwich Arts Centre, hosts Dougald Hine and Giles Gentile are joined by special guests Charlotte Du Cann and Rupert Read. They discuss the origins of the podcast and the importance of humility in climate discussions. They explore wake-up calls to the environmental crisis, the difference between a problem and a predicament, the role of precaution in the climate crisis, and disappointment with certain authors' stances on COVID-19. They also delve into the relationship between energy and fossil fuels.
Using the language of emergency can mobilize action in climate movements and expand understanding of the crisis.
The framing of the climate crisis as a predicament and embracing vulnerability can foster collaborative and community-driven responses.
The reliance on climate engineering and geoengineering may perpetuate destructive logics and hinder meaningful collective action in addressing climate change.
Deep dives
The Power of Culture and Language in Addressing the Climate Crisis
There is value in using the language of emergency, as it has mobilized people and sparked action in climate movements. Culture can play a powerful role in questioning and expanding understanding of the crisis, allowing for imagination and a wider focus on the Earth crisis. The language of emergency can be reframed to foster more democracy and engage diverse perspectives.
Moving from Problem to Predicament: Embracing Vulnerability and Loss
Shifting the framing from a problem-solving approach to acknowledging the predicament of the climate crisis opens up the possibility of democratic and community-driven responses. Embracing vulnerability and grief without succumbing to fear and denial is key. This reframing invites collaboration, care, and the building of resilient community infrastructures.
Surprises and Disappointments
One surprise in the book was the emphasis on the role of science in addressing the climate crisis. However, a suggestion was made for the book to further explore the precautionary principle, which allows for action even when scientific certainty is lacking. As for disappointments, one critique related to the discussion on COVID-19, where it was felt that the implications of certain claims were not fully addressed.
The importance of community and collective action
The podcast episode emphasizes the significance of coming together as a community to address the challenges of our crumbling civilization. It highlights the need for diverse voices and perspectives, moving away from individualism, and creating spaces for meaningful dialogue and collaboration. By breaking out of our individualistic mindset and nurturing empathy, we can work towards a future that focuses on resilience, caring for one another, and softening the impact of our changing world.
The dangers of relying on technology and science
The podcast raises concerns about the reliance on climate engineering and geoengineering as potential solutions to climate change. It explores the idea that such approaches, like deploying mirrors in space, may perpetuate the destructive logics of modernity and prioritize maintaining the current civilization over addressing root causes. The podcast encourages reevaluating the role of science and technology, acknowledging that science alone cannot provide all the answers for climate change. It suggests moving beyond individual heroism and reimagining agency in collective action, questioning assumptions about where power and agency lie in addressing the challenges of our times.
In February this year, we took The Great Humbling into a new format, a live conversation on stage at Norwich Arts Centre as part of the UK tour that Dougald made to launch his book, At Work in the Ruins. It's taken us rather a long time to get the recording edited, but here it is at last.
For this live show, Ed and Dougald were joined by two special guests.
Charlotte Du Cann is a writer, editor, teacher and lover of all things rooted in Earth and sky. She works as co-director of the Dark Mountain Project and is the author of After Ithaca and 52 Flowers That Shook My World. She has just launched her Substack, The Red Tent, 'a metaphysical practice for collapsing times', in which she writes to pass on the tools that have served her over the past thirty years.
Rupert Read is a philosopher and climate activist. This summer, he left his role as a professor at the University of East Anglia, after 26 years, to dedicate himself to his work as co-director of the Climate Majority Project. He is the author of many books, including Why Climate Breakdown Matters and Do You Want to Know the Truth? The Surprising Rewards of Climate Honesty.
We'll be back in a few weeks' time with the first episode of our fifth season.
This is a public episode. If you would like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit www.homewardbound.org
Get the Snipd podcast app
Unlock the knowledge in podcasts with the podcast player of the future.
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode
Save any moment
Hear something you like? Tap your headphones to save it with AI-generated key takeaways
Share & Export
Send highlights to Twitter, WhatsApp or export them to Notion, Readwise & more
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode