This podcast explores the fracture of French society during the Revolution, discussing topics like the first Bastille Day, the Catholic counter-revolution, the rise of radicalism, and revolutionary violence.
47:56
AI Summary
AI Chapters
Episode notes
auto_awesome
Podcast summary created with Snipd AI
Quick takeaways
The Feast of the Federation projected an image of unity, but French society remained deeply divided, revealing the growing factionalism and conflicts within the country.
The conflict between revolutionary ideals and religious beliefs, notably concerning freedom of religion and church property, led to a split between those loyal to the government and those loyal to the Pope, escalating civil conflict during the revolution.
Deep dives
The Feast of the Federation
In July 1790, the French revolutionary government organized an extravagant event called the Feast of the Federation. Over 100,000 people attended the festival, which aimed to symbolize the unity and acceptance of a moderate constitutional monarchy envisioned by the liberal bourgeoisie. The event featured a Catholic mass, a grand oath-swearing ceremony led by Marquis de Lafayette, and four days of celebration with food, wine, music, and dancing. Although the festival projected an image of unity, the reality was that French society remained deeply divided, and the momentary display of consensus did not reflect the growing factionalism and conflicts within the country.
Religious Division
The revolutionary government's religious policies, such as freedom of religion and the Civil Constitution of the clergy, sparked division and resistance among Catholics. Conservative Catholics viewed the reforms as attacks on their faith and the power of the Catholic Church. The government's confiscation of church property to address financial issues further alienated the clergy and fueled opposition. The conflict between revolutionary ideals and religious beliefs led to a split between those who swore oaths of loyalty to the government (durings) and those who remained loyal to the Pope (non-durings). This religious division contributed to the escalation of civil conflict during the revolution.
Emigres and Counter-Revolutionaries
Numerous nobles and members of the aristocracy, known as emigres, fled France and formed counter-revolutionary movements. They sought to restore the old power structure and traditional systems while rejecting the revolutionary changes. The emigres used their transnational connections, money, and influence to support foreign powers against the revolution. Although their direct impact on the revolution and the Napoleonic Wars was limited, the fear of emigre plots and their indirect support to France's enemies exacerbated tensions and shaped events during this period.
Bourgeoisie and Urban Poor
The bourgeoisie, primarily consisting of the middle class liberals, and the urban poor, formed a loose coalition in the early days of the revolution against the monarchy. However, as the revolution progressed, their differences and conflicting goals became evident. The bourgeoisie desired constitutional reforms and focused on political and legal rights, while the urban poor sought economic justice and improvements to their living conditions. The growing disparity in their interests and perspectives fueled the divergence and strained the unity of the revolutionaries.
French society begins to fracture as the Revolution goes off the rails. Topics include the first Bastille Day, the Catholic counter-revolution, the émigrés, the rise of radicalism, and revolutionary violence