America’s Founders Feared a Caesar. Has One Arrived?
Mar 8, 2025
auto_awesome
Jeffrey Rosen, President and CEO of the National Constitution Center and a law professor at George Washington University, discusses the founders' fears of tyranny and draws parallels between Donald Trump's leadership style and Julius Caesar's dictatorship. The conversation delves into the cyclical nature of political power, the implications of executive overreach, and how the Supreme Court is responding to these challenges. Rosen emphasizes the importance of understanding history to avoid repeating the mistakes of the past as America grapples with the rise of demagoguery.
The podcast discusses the founding fathers' fears of a Caesar-like figure emerging in America, reflecting on historical patterns of institutional decay.
It highlights the current balance of power struggles between the executive branch and Congress, revealing concerns over unchecked presidential authority.
Deep dives
Legal Retribution and Its Implications
Former President Trump is targeting law firms associated with the Democrats and the investigators involved in his legal challenges, aiming to penalize them by stripping security clearances and restricting their access to federal buildings. This appears to be an attempt to intimidate legal representatives considering similar cases, sending a message of retribution against those who oppose him. Such actions reflect a personal vendetta and raise concerns regarding the broader implications for legal conduct and the independence of legal institutions in the face of political retaliation. The potential chilling effect on other law firms is significant, signaling that involvement in politically charged investigations may result in punitive actions from political figures.
Historical Comparisons: Democracy Under Threat
The podcast draws parallels between contemporary political tensions in America and historical moments of institutional decay, particularly the fall of the Roman Republic. The discussion highlights that America's founding fathers were deeply concerned with the emergence of a Caesar-like figure who could undermine democratic institutions. This perspective prompts a reflection on whether the current political landscape resembles past eras of music, such as the Civil War or the rise of authoritarian rule. By exploring how previous republics succumbed to concentrated power, the dialogue emphasizes the urgency for vigilance against similar paths in today's governance.
The Founders' Fears: The Rise of a Caesar
The founding fathers, particularly Alexander Hamilton and Thomas Jefferson, had diverging views on the dangers of concentrated power, with both fearing the emergence of a dictator. Hamilton’s admiration for strength in leadership, coupled with his concern over populism’s risks, suggests a complex attitude toward power dynamics. Jefferson, on the other hand, worried that a future authoritarian leader could exploit popular sentiment to usurp elections and install themselves as a tyrant. This historical lens raises critical questions about how current political figures may embody these fears and challenge the foundational democratic principles established by the framers.
The Battle for Checks and Balances
The ongoing struggle between the executive branch and Congress reflects a significant constitutional crisis, culminating in discussions about the effectiveness of checks and balances in the current political environment. Historically, the founders intended for Congress to be a robust counter to presidential power, but contemporary dynamics indicate a retreat from these institutional responsibilities, enabling executive overreach. As the judiciary grapples with pivotal cases concerning executive power, the role of Congress in asserting its authority becomes increasingly crucial. Without proactive steps from Congress, the potential for an unchecked presidency grows, threatening the balance that was meticulously crafted by the founding fathers.
The Washington Roundtable speaks with Jeffrey Rosen, the president and C.E.O. of the National Constitution Center, a nonpartisan nonprofit, about how America’s founders tried to tyrant-proof their constitutional system, how Donald Trump’s whim-based decision-making resembles that of the dictator Julius Caesar, and what we can learn from the fall of the Roman Republic. Plus, how the Supreme Court is responding to the Trump Administration’s broad claims of executive power.
To discover more podcasts from The New Yorker, visit newyorker.com/podcasts. To send in feedback on this episode, write to themail@newyorker.com with “The Political Scene” in the subject line.