Filmspotting All the President's Men (Archive)
Oct 8, 2025
The hosts reflect on Robert Redford and delve into the enduring impact of a classic film centered on journalism rather than its political scandal. They discuss its relevance during modern times, alongside the craftsmanship that elevates its story. The tactile atmosphere of the newsroom is praised, emphasizing the use of sound design to create tension without a score. Standout performances, particularly by Jason Robards and Hal Holbrook, are highlighted for their role in adding emotional depth and realism to the narrative.
AI Snips
Chapters
Books
Transcript
Episode notes
Film Focuses On Journalistic Process
- All the President's Men is less about Watergate and more about the craft of journalism and persistent reporting.
- Adam and Josh say the film dramatizes process, grit, and the procedural nature of investigative work.
Restraint Equals Thrilling Craft
- The movie succeeds as filmmaking as much as journalism, delivering restrained, deliberate storytelling that still thrills.
- Adam calls it a procedural about work, praising the writing, performances, and Pakula's direction.
Host's Early Reporting Experience
- Josh shares that his early reporting work at a local paper taught him the rhythms of making calls, getting hung up on, and chasing quotes.
- He says that experience made the film's procedures feel like a thrilling re-immersion into reporting craft.
