Sara Protasi, "The Philosophy of Envy" (Cambridge UP, 2022)
Aug 29, 2023
auto_awesome
Philosopher and author Sara Protasi discusses the multifaceted nature of envy and its various forms. She explores the ethical implications of envy and how it can motivate individuals to level down or level up. The podcast also explores the potential benefits of envy in terms of motivation, competition, and personal growth. Additionally, it delves into the presence of envy in relationships and its historical context, including the discrimination faced by Asian immigrants in the United States. The concept of political envy and its impact on group unity and political change is also explored.
Envy is a complex emotion that can be categorized into different types, such as amotive envy, inert envy, aggressive envy, and spiteful envy, and it can arise even in relationships we cherish.
Political envy, entangled with jealousy and resentment, can arise within social groups and have detrimental effects on social cohesion and lead to discriminatory policies.
Deep dives
Liberation Day: A Masterful Story Collection by George Saunders
Liberation Day is a thought-provoking story collection that delves into ideas of power, ethics, and justice. With tales encompassing joy, despair, oppression, and revolution, George Saunders challenges and surprises readers. Examples include Love Letter, a tender story set in a dystopian future, Ghoul, which explores a health-themed amusement park in Colorado, and Mother's Day, a tale of two women confronting their shared love for the same man. Liberation Day is now available in paperback, offering readers immersive and thought-provoking narratives.
The Philosophy of Envy: An Interview with Dr. Sara Protasi
Dr. Sara Protasi, an assistant professor of philosophy, sheds light on the complex topic of envy. In her book, The Philosophy of Envy, she explores emotions, the perception of control, and whether envy is morally or prudentially bad. She notes that envy is a complex emotion that can be categorized into different types, such as amotive envy, inert envy, aggressive envy, and spiteful envy. Dr. Protasi also discusses the intersection of envy and love, and how envy can arise even in relationships we cherish. She opines that envy can be a transitional emotion, but its negative effects should be acknowledged and addressed to maintain healthy relationships.
Political Envy: A Complex Emotion in Sociopolitical Contexts
Political envy is a nuanced emotion that arises within social groups and has political implications. Dr. Sara Protasi emphasizes that envy in the political sphere can be entangled with jealousy and resentment. She highlights how social identity, such as race and gender, can trigger political envy, leading to divisions and rivalries. Additionally, she explores racialized envy, where envy is experienced across racial lines. Dr. Protasi cautions against the dangers of political envy, as it can undermine social cohesion and lead to discriminatory policies. While political envy may occasionally serve as a transitional emotion, it should be carefully examined and managed to prevent negative consequences.
Future Projects: Exploring Love, Envy, Fear, and Courage
Dr. Sara Protasi is currently working on a new book that further delves into the themes of love and envy in a more accessible manner. She aims to explore the dynamics of these emotions in relationships and the potential impact on individuals. Additionally, she is interested in studying fear and courage within the context of social relationships. Dr. Protasi believes that many immoral behaviors stem from fear and hopes to shed light on the importance of courage in navigating social interactions. Her future projects seek to uncover the complex interplay between emotions and human relationships.
Envy is almost universally condemned and feared. But is its bad reputation always warranted? In The Philosophy of Envy (Cambridge UP, 2022), Sara Protasi argues that envy is more multifaceted than it seems, and that some varieties of it can be productive and even virtuous. Protasi brings together empirical evidence and philosophical research to generate a novel view according to which there are four kinds of envy: emulative, inert, aggressive, and spiteful. For each kind, she individuates different situational antecedents, phenomenological expressions, motivational tendencies, and behavioral outputs. She then develops the normative implications of this taxonomy from a moral and prudential perspective, in the domain of personal loving relationships, and in the political sphere. A historical appendix completes the book. Through a careful and comprehensive investigation of envy's complexity, and its multifarious implications for human relations and human value, The Philosophy of Envy surprisingly reveals that envy plays a crucial role in safeguarding our happiness.
Sara Protasi is Associate Professor of Philosophy at the University of Puget Sound
Morteza Hajizadeh is a Ph.D. graduate in English from the University of Auckland in New Zealand. His research interests are Cultural Studies; Critical Theory; Environmental History; Medieval (Intellectual) History; Gothic Studies; 18th and 19th Century British Literature. YouTube channel.