Intelligence Squared The Sunday Debate: Anti-Zionism is Anti-Semitism
Jul 18, 2021
In a compelling discussion, journalist Melanie Phillips and former Knesset member Einat Wilf argue that anti-Zionism often overlaps with anti-Semitism. In contrast, historian Ilan Pappé and journalist Mehdi Hasan challenge this notion, advocating for a deeper understanding of political critique versus prejudice. The debate dives into the historical context of anti-Zionism, the unique critique of Israel, and the implications of societal crises on anti-Jewish sentiments. A heated exchange highlights the complexities of these intertwined issues and the need for nuanced dialogue.
AI Snips
Chapters
Transcript
Episode notes
Melanie Phillips's Israel Visit
- Melanie Phillips didn't want to visit Israel until 2000.
- She was surprised to be attacked as a Jew for defending Israel.
Definitions of Zionism and Anti-Semitism
- Zionism is the Jewish people's self-determination in their ancient homeland.
- Anti-Semitism is the delusional hatred and fear of Jews.
Jewish Anti-Zionism
- Some Jews are anti-Zionist, like Karl Marx.
- A fringe group of ultra-Orthodox Jews oppose Israel's current state but not Jewish peoplehood.