This podcast explores three instances of scientific breakthroughs that turned out to be mistakes: faster-than-light neutrinos, the cold fusion claim, and the chocolate weight loss hoax. It highlights the importance of research and the ease with which outrageous claims can be made.
The 2012 announcement of faster-than-light neutrinos was later proven to be a fault in the fiber-opt cable, validating Einstein's theories of relativity.
The cold fusion claim in 1989 by Fleischman and Pons was debunked, highlighting the importance of reproducibility in scientific experiments.
Deep dives
Scientific research mistakes: Einstein was wrong about exceeding the speed of light
In 2012, the European Council for Nuclear Research (CERN) announced a groundbreaking discovery that neutrinos had exceeded the speed of light, challenging Einstein's theories of relativity. However, it was later discovered that there was a fault in the fiber-opt cable, proving that Einstein's theories were accurate.
Failed attempt at achieving cold fusion by electrochemists at the University of Utah
In 1989, Martin Fleischman and Stanley Pons claimed to have achieved cold fusion, a type of room temperature nuclear reaction. The news garnered attention and hopes for a revolutionary and safe energy source. However, other scientists could not replicate their results, leading to the consensus that they had made mistakes in their experiments.
Misleading claims about the link between chocolate and weight loss
A journalist named John Bahannan created a fictional Institute of Diet and Health and conducted a study claiming that eating a bar of chocolate daily helped people on a low carbohydrate diet lose weight faster. This story was picked up by news outlets worldwide without proper fact-checking. Bahannan aimed to showcase how poorly designed experiments could become news and mislead the public.
Become a Pro Member and get “Students of Murder” course (normally €49) for free: https://bit.ly/Jan2025Offer
---
Millions worldwide dedicate their lives to research, striving for medical breakthroughs and enhancing our understanding of the human body. But occasionally, they make mistakes.
In this episode, we'll explore three instances where scientific breakthroughs were announced but later proven to be mistakes.
Scientific Studies in Media
Case 1: Faster Than Light Neutrinos
2012 CERN press conference: Einstein was wrong
Investigation reveals a fault in the fibre optic cable
Case 2: Cold Fusion Fiasco
1989 claim of "cold fusion" by electrochemists Fleischmann and Pons
Experiment flaws exposed; Fleischmann and Pons discredited
Case 3: Chocolate and Weight Loss Hoax
2015 false claim: Eating chocolate aids low-carb diet weight loss
Researcher John Bohannon exposes the ease of making outrageous claims