Advisory Opinions Merry Christmas to the State Courts
Dec 25, 2025
Carlos G. Muñiz, Chief Justice of the Florida Supreme Court, shares insights on Florida's judicial selection and the unique powers of state courts. He reveals how local nominating commissions influence appointments and explains the complexities of Florida’s docket, which includes both business and family law. The discussion also touches on the challenges of originalism in state constitutions and the role of AI in enhancing access to justice for pro se litigants, highlighting the significance of state courts in everyday legal matters.
AI Snips
Chapters
Transcript
Episode notes
State Courts Are The Real Daily Backbone
- State supreme courts handle the vast majority of cases that affect everyday lives and businesses.
- Their jurisprudence often matters more to practitioners than the U.S. Supreme Court's decisions.
Appointment Then Immediate Election Pressure
- Evan Young described being appointed then immediately facing primary and general elections within months.
- He won both and then faced a regular six-year term and the need to run again in 2028.
Use Business Courts To Speed Complex Cases
- Use specialized courts to improve efficiency for complex cases and free generalist judges.
- Appoint experienced trial judges with staff to handle complex business litigation promptly.