Yascha Mounk discusses the dominance of identity politics, the power of post-modernism, critical race theory and intersectionality, teaching 'stupid things' to privileged children, family history and identity, challenges of being a college administrator, and embracing universal principles.
The rise of identity politics has led to a tension between the left and the right, with the right attacking everything associated with it and the left dismissing any critique of it.
The identity synthesis, influenced by post-modernism, post-colonialism, and critical race theory, proposes that race, gender, and sexual orientation are the primary prisms through which the world should be understood, leading to a skepticism towards universal principles and a focus on intersectionality.
The focus on victimhood in identity politics contributes to a divisive nature of politics and discourse, and there is a need for a more nuanced approach that recognizes agency, individual responsibility, and collective progress.
Deep dives
The Identity Trap: Understanding the Dominance of Identity Politics
In this podcast episode, Yasha Monk, the founder of the online magazine Persuasion and author of The Identity Trap, discusses the rise of identity politics and its negative influence on society. He argues that there is a tension between the right and the left when it comes to discussing these ideas, with the right sometimes attacking everything associated with identity politics and the left dismissing any critique of it. Monk delves into the intellectual history of these ideas, tracing their origins in the academy and their subsequent influence on society. He also explores the key components of this ideology, including the focus on race, gender, and sexual orientation, the skepticism towards universal principles, and the call for a regime where treatment and societal norms depend on group identity. Monk highlights the importance of engaging in a serious conversation about these ideas while also critiquing them and striving to live up to universal liberal values. He acknowledges that there has been pushback against extreme manifestations of this ideology, but cautions against the deeper hold it may be gaining in various institutions and classrooms.
The Identity Synthesis: Unveiling the Core of Identity Politics
The identity synthesis, as Yasha Monk calls it, refers to the convergence of different intellectual influences such as post-modernism, post-colonialism, and critical race theory, which have shaped contemporary discussions and practices related to identity politics. Monk argues that the key proposition of the identity synthesis is that race, gender, and sexual orientation are the primary prisms through which the world should be understood. Alongside this, there is a skepticism towards universal principles and a belief that institutions and societal norms perpetuate discrimination and dominance. These ideas have led to strategies like strategic essentialism and the advocacy for intersectionality. By acknowledging the historical origins and ongoing influence of the identity synthesis, Monk emphasizes the need to critically examine its premises and consider alternative perspectives that recognize the complexities and interplay of various identities.
Critiquing Victimology: Examining the Destructive Nature of Victimhood
In response to the concept of victimology, Monk expresses concern over its destructive impact. He agrees with the view put forth by Thomas Sowell, calling it self-destructive. The focus on victimhood, according to Monk, contributes to a divisive nature of politics and discourse. While acknowledging the legacies of discrimination and oppression, Monk advocates for a more nuanced approach that recognizes agency, individual responsibility, and the importance of striving for collective progress. He suggests moving away from a culture of victimization and victimhood towards an ethos that empowers individuals to overcome obstacles and actively engage in creating positive change.
The influence of social media and popularized versions
The podcast episode discusses the role of social media platforms like Tumblr in popularizing the concept of identities and encouraging people to define themselves in terms of their identities. This meta ideology of identity synthesis found a stronghold through platforms like Fort Catalock and everydayfeminism.com, eventually making its way into mainstream discourse and media outlets like Vox and The New York Times.
The impact of events and political shifts
The episode explores how certain events and political shifts acted as tipping points in bringing identity issues to the forefront of popular consciousness. The disappointment with the post-racial narrative following Obama's election, along with the election of Donald Trump, played significant roles. The rise of Trump and his administration's policies led many to redirect their attention towards controllable spaces, including identity-focused ideas. It also created an environment where in-group critics were treated as traitors, hindering healthy debate and reinforcing identity-based ideologies.
The Identity Trap explains how identity politics and social justice discourse have come to dominate contemporary discussions of just about everything, analyzes their negative influence on society, and shows how to confront and defeat them in the name of liberal values of free expression and open inquiry.
Yascha was a prime mover behind the 2020 open letter on "justice and open debate" in Harper's magazine and is one of the most powerful defenders of free speech and the marketplace of ideas at work today.
This interview took place at the Reason Speakeasy, a live, unscripted monthly conversation held in New York City with outspoken defenders of free speech and heterodox thinking. Go here for information about upcoming events.
Today's sponsor:
BetterHelp. Are you at your best? Working with a therapist can help you get closer to the best version of you—because when you feel empowered, you're more prepared to take on everything life throws at you. If you're thinking of giving therapy a try, BetterHelp is a great option. It's convenient, flexible, affordable, and entirely online. Just fill out a brief questionnaire to get matched with a licensed therapist, and switch therapists anytime for no additional charge. If you want to live a more empowered life, therapy can get you there.