Keen On America Episode 2282: Adam Kirsch on the nonsense of "Settler Colonialism"
Dec 24, 2024
Adam Kirsch, a published poet and cultural critic, delves into the complexities of settler colonialism in his latest work. He discusses how simplistic narratives fail to capture the intricacies of American and Israeli histories. Kirsch emphasizes the importance of nuanced language, particularly in the context of the Israeli-Palestinian conflict. He critiques the effect of modern discourse on historical understanding and advocates for thoughtful dialogue that transcends polarizing rhetoric. The episode also touches on how boycotts can undermine literary engagement.
AI Snips
Chapters
Books
Transcript
Episode notes
Settler Colonialism’s Evolving Meaning
- The term "settler colonialism" has evolved from describing a small settler class ruling over a larger native population to characterizing societies where settlers or immigrants comprise the vast majority.
- This shift implies a fundamental flaw within these societies due to their colonial origins, rather than a practical call for settlers to leave.
The Rousseauian Influence and the Counter-Myth of America
- The concept of settler colonialism draws parallels with Rousseau's romanticism, idealizing pre-colonial societies while critiquing modern Western civilization.
- This creates a counter-myth, portraying European settlers as uniquely savage and morally primitive.
Genocide, Guilt, and Belonging
- While acknowledging the historical genocide associated with European settlement, Kirsch questions the implications for the 21st century.
- The settler colonialism framework assigns guilt and lack of belonging to anyone not of indigenous descent, potentially undermining the legitimacy of these societies.
