Coffee House Shots The Mandelson scandal could spell the end for Starmer
Feb 4, 2026
Isabel Hardman, political journalist and author, offers sharp analysis of Starmer’s image and process-driven style. Tim Shipman, political commentator, breaks down parliamentary tactics and security questions. They dissect the Mandelson controversy, Starmer’s PMQ performance, scrutiny of oversight, and whether this scandal shifts momentum in Westminster.
AI Snips
Chapters
Books
Transcript
Episode notes
Process Over Perception
- Keir Starmer leans on process and propriety, which blinds him to public perception and political vulnerability.
- That overreliance made his PMQ defence on Peter Mandelson seem tone-deaf and defensive.
The Damning Admission
- Kemi Badenoch forced Starmer to admit he and security services knew about Mandelson's Epstein links after conviction.
- That admission was the pivotal omission that undermined Starmer's narrative at PMQs.
Use Independent Oversight
- Use an independent body like the Intelligence and Security Committee to review sensitive documents rather than sole Cabinet Office control.
- Involve a more visibly impartial mechanism to avoid claims of a cover-up.
