An IPO drought pushes investors to a murky marketplace
Jan 17, 2024
auto_awesome
This podcast discusses the rise of venture secondary markets as IPOs and acquisitions slow down in Silicon Valley. It explores the challenges and differences of trading in these markets, the creation of Carter X to simplify share selling, a scandal involving startup Carter, and the lack of transparency in the trade and venture secondaries market.
The slowdown in initial public offerings and acquisitions has created a demand for the venture secondary market, where investors and early employees can trade stakes in privately-held companies.
The venture secondary market lacks transparency and regulation, making it potentially prone to manipulation and fraud.
Deep dives
Importance of company stock in attracting employees
Silicon Valley startups have been using company stock as a major incentive for attracting new employees. Stock options are often seen as more valuable than salary since they have the potential to turn into significant wealth if the company succeeds. However, the recent slowdown in the venture capital market, with higher interest rates and reduced IPOs, has caused a liquidity problem for employees who hold stocks in privately held companies. This has led to a growing demand for alternative solutions such as the venture secondary market, where professional investors and employees can trade stakes in companies before they go public.
Risks and challenges in the venture secondary market
The venture secondary market operates differently from the public stock market, with lower liquidity and trading based on limited information. Valuation of private companies in this market depends on appraisals of growth potential rather than clear financial data. The market consists of two main groups: those directly holding stakes in startups, such as early employees and angel investors, and institutional investors like pension funds and university endowments. However, the market lacks transparency and regulation, making it potentially prone to manipulation and fraud.
Carter's attempt to formalize the venture secondary market
Carter, a company involved in cap table management for startups, attempted to create a more transparent and formalized secondary market called Carter X. The marketplace aimed to facilitate the trading of shares in private companies and had initially received significant investments, valuing the company at billions of dollars. However, the venture secondary market didn't develop as expected, and Carter X faced challenges due to declining valuations and conflicts between startups and employees seeking liquidity. Moreover, a recent scandal revealed a breach of trust when Carter employees allegedly used confidential data to facilitate trades. As a result, Carter X was ultimately shut down.
In Silicon Valley, the promise of a massive payday for a start-up’s early employees and investors has hinged on those companies eventually going public or being sold off. But with the slowdown in initial public offerings and acquisitions, a different marketplace is set to heat up this year. It is called the venture secondary market, and it’s where both investors and early employees can trade their stakes in privately-held companies. The FT’s venture capital correspondent George Hammond explains the potential pitfalls of this opaque marketplace and why investors will be rushing to it in 2024.